2023 rookie draft board

D3 Dynasty League · 60 picks · 5 rounds · 12 teams · season 2023 · all drafts · Manager report cards
Speed
Pick 0 of 60
RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.
RD
Jared Nutter
the Skeet
Josh Bayer
Tommarello
Keetz
Carson Nutter
CJ Nutter
Jordon Nutter
Bryan Stein
Eric Harper
Talon Cain
Charles Hartz
1
#1 BijanATL RB
Robinson
#8 QuentinLAC WR
Johnston
#2 JahmyrDET RB
Gibbs
#4 BryceCAR QB
Young
#3 AnthonyIND QB
Richardson
#7 JordanMIN WR
Addison
#5 C.J.HOU QB
Stroud
#10 ZayBAL WR
Flowers
#6 JaxonSEA WR
Smith-Njigba
#9 DaltonBUF TE
Kincaid
#12 JonathanCAR WR
Mingo
#11 De'VonMIA RB
Achane
No selection
No selection
No selection
No selection
No selection
2
#13 WillTEN QB
Levis
#20 MarvinDEN WR
Mims
#14 ZachSEA RB
Charbonnet
#23 SamDET TE
LaPorta
#15 JoshIND WR
Downs
#22 RoschonCHI RB
Johnson
No selection
No selection
No selection
#16 JaydenGB WR
Reed
#19 MichaelLV TE
Mayer
#17 RasheeKC WR
Rice
#18 KendreNO RB
Miller
#21 TankJAX RB
Bigsby
#24 JalinNYG WR
Hyatt
No selection
No selection
3
#30 TankHOU WR
Dell
No selection
#27 LukeGB TE
Musgrave
#33 ZachLAR RB
Evans
#34 IsraelNYJ RB
Abanikanda
#32 MichaelARI WR
Wilson
#35 KayshonNE WR
Boutte
#25 TyjaeTEN RB
Spears
#31 CedricCLE WR
Tillman
#29 LukeDAL TE
Schoonmaker
#26 HendonDET QB
Hooker
#36 DeuceDAL RB
Vaughn
#28 ChaseCIN RB
Brown
No selection
4
#37 PukaLAR WR
Nacua
#39 ChrisWAS RB
Rodriguez
#41 CharlieCIN WR
Jones
#46 TuckerGB TE
Kraft
#44 XavierHOU WR
Hutchinson
#47 BrentonJAX TE
Strange
#42 DeWayneMIN RB
McBride
No selection
#38 StetsonLAR QB
Bennett
#45 A.T.NO WR
Perry
#48 TylerCHI WR
Scott
No selection
#40 SeanTB RB
Tucker
#43 DarnellPIT TE
Washington
5
#49 TreyTB WR
Palmer
#53 JustinBUF WR
Shorter
#50 EvanIND RB
Hull
#51 EricNYG RB
Gray
#58 MalikDAL RB
Davis
#56 ZackNYJ TE
Kuntz
#59 DontayvionGB WR
Wicks
#54 TreLV WR
Tucker
No selection
#57 ParkerJAX WR
Washington
#60 KeatonBAL RB
Mitchell
No selection
#52 KennySEA RB
McIntosh
#55 DorianCLE QB
Thompson-Robinson
Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

the Skeet A

johndennis · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +56.7 points · total +339.9 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Sam LaPorta (#23, +207.3). Worst pick: Bryce Young (#4, -18.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#2 / R1Jahmyr Gibbs RBthe Skeet242.1116.9+125.2
#4 / R1Bryce Young QBTalon Cain · traded pick90.2108.3-18.0
#14 / R2Zach Charbonnet RBthe Skeet95.652.1+43.5
#23 / R2Sam LaPorta TECarson Nutter · traded pick230.423.1+207.3
#39 / R4Chris Rodriguez RBJosh Bayer · traded pick0.012.2-12.2
#50 / R5Evan Hull RBthe Skeet0.05.8-5.8

Jared Nutter B

Jnut · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: +47.8 points · total +382.2 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Puka Nacua (#37, +263.9). Worst pick: Quentin Johnston (#8, -66.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#1 / R1Bijan Robinson RBJared Nutter219.0120.6+98.4
#8 / R1Quentin Johnston WRKeetz · traded pick19.986.1-66.2
#13 / R2Will Levis QBJared Nutter42.758.4-15.7
#20 / R2Marvin Mims WRKeetz · traded pick25.329.8-4.5
#30 / R3Tank Dell WRCJ Nutter · traded pick132.312.9+119.4
#37 / R4Puka Nacua WRJared Nutter276.612.7+263.9
#49 / R5Trey Palmer WRJared Nutter0.06.1-6.1
#53 / R5Justin Shorter WRJordon Nutter · traded pick0.07.0-7.0

Tommarello B

The Rebuild · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: +39.4 points · total +197.1 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: C.J. Stroud (#5, +138.0). Worst pick: Israel Abanikanda (#34, -12.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#5 / R1C.J. Stroud QBJordon Nutter · traded pick242.5104.5+138.0
#10 / R1Zay Flowers WRNot recorded163.273.9+89.3
#34 / R3Israel Abanikanda RBNot recorded0.012.7-12.7
#46 / R4Tucker Kraft TENot recorded0.08.7-8.7
#58 / R5Malik Davis RBNot recorded0.08.7-8.7

CJ Nutter C

Ripley's Reapers · 7 picks · 7 graded

Average vs slot: +21.4 points · total +149.9 ÷ 7 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jayden Reed (#16, +134.0). Worst pick: Michael Mayer (#19, -32.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#11 / R1De'Von Achane RBCarson Nutter · traded pick137.568.8+68.7
#16 / R2Jayden Reed WRTalon Cain · traded pick176.942.9+134.0
#19 / R2Michael Mayer TECharles Hartz · traded pick0.032.3-32.3
#25 / R3Tyjae Spears RBJared Nutter · traded pick28.517.4+11.1
#31 / R3Cedric Tillman WRCharles Hartz · traded pick0.013.4-13.4
#42 / R4DeWayne McBride RBCJ Nutter0.010.5-10.5
#54 / R5Tre Tucker WRCJ Nutter0.07.7-7.7

Josh Bayer C

Very Good Construction Co · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: +16.3 points · total +130.0 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jordan Addison (#7, +124.5). Worst pick: Anthony Richardson (#3, -39.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#3 / R1Anthony Richardson QBJosh Bayer72.7112.3-39.6
#7 / R1Jordan Addison WRCharles Hartz · traded pick221.396.8+124.5
#15 / R2Josh Downs WRJosh Bayer129.747.5+82.2
#22 / R2Roschon Johnson RBNot recorded29.726.9+2.8
#27 / R3Luke Musgrave TEJosh Bayer6.815.8-9.0
#33 / R3Zach Evans RBBryan Stein · traded pick0.013.6-13.6
#41 / R4Charlie Jones WRJordon Nutter · traded pick0.011.5-11.5
#51 / R5Eric Gray RBJosh Bayer0.05.8-5.8

Carson Nutter D

Rest In Piss Queen Lizzy · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -3.2 points · total -16.0 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Dalton Kincaid (#9, +48.2). Worst pick: Jonathan Mingo (#12, -48.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#9 / R1Dalton Kincaid TEBryan Stein · traded pick128.280.0+48.2
#12 / R1Jonathan Mingo WREric Harper · traded pick15.363.5-48.2
#35 / R3Kayshon Boutte WRCarson Nutter0.013.2-13.2
#47 / R4Brenton Strange TECarson Nutter0.07.6-7.6
#59 / R5Dontayvion Wicks WRCarson Nutter11.36.6+4.7

Bryan Stein F

Dilly's Destroyers · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: -15.6 points · total -125.0 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Tyler Scott (#48, -6.8). Worst pick: Kendre Miller (#18, -36.5).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#18 / R2Kendre Miller RBCJ Nutter · traded pick0.036.5-36.5
#21 / R2Tank Bigsby RBBryan Stein0.028.6-28.6
#26 / R3Hendon Hooker QBthe Skeet · traded pick0.016.4-16.4
#38 / R4Stetson Bennett QBthe Skeet · traded pick0.012.2-12.2
#45 / R4A.T. Perry WRBryan Stein0.08.2-8.2
#48 / R4Tyler Scott WREric Harper · traded pick0.06.8-6.8
#57 / R5Parker Washington WRBryan Stein0.09.2-9.2
#60 / R5Keaton Mitchell RBEric Harper · traded pick0.07.2-7.2

Eric Harper F

2 Girls 1 Kupp · 2 picks · 2 graded

Average vs slot: -16.4 points · total -32.8 ÷ 2 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Deuce Vaughn (#36, -13.2). Worst pick: Jalin Hyatt (#24, -19.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#24 / R2Jalin Hyatt WREric Harper0.019.6-19.6
#36 / R3Deuce Vaughn RBEric Harper0.013.2-13.2