2,904 picks · its own slot baseline
The draft room
6,446 picks across 49 drafts and 5 leagues. Report cards use year-one scored-lineup production relative to nearby picks of the same draft type—not reputation, career value, or hindsight vibes.
1,104 picks · its own slot baseline
1,692 picks · its own slot baseline
746 picks · preserved as roster snapshots, never graded
Recent report cards
Too early for production grades
Too early for production grades
Too early for production grades
Carson Nutter led at +57.3 per graded pick
Bryan Stein led at +40.0 per graded pick
CJ Nutter led at +56.1 per graded pick
Jordon Nutter led at +41.5 per graded pick
Keetz led at +56.3 per graded pick
codyis led at +143.8 per graded pick
Derek Glover led at +24.9 per graded pick
Jordon Nutter led at +49.7 per graded pick
Lorenz led at +62.2 per graded pick
Every draft
Biggest year-one steals
| Year | Type | Pick | Player | Manager | Y1 pts | vs slot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #141 (R12) | Lamar Jackson QB | Jordon Nutter | 416 | +363 |
| 2021 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #50 (R5) | Cooper Kupp WR | CJ Nutter | 413 | +285 |
| 2024 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #49 (R4) | Lamar Jackson QB | Jordon Nutter | 407 | +277 |
| 2025 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #138 (R10) | Drake Maye QB | Nick Moretti | 320 | +276 |
| 2022 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #51 (R5) | Patrick Mahomes QB | The Drake | 402 | +274 |
| 2018 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #125 (R11) | Patrick Mahomes QB | The Drake | 333 | +273 |
| 2024 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #119 (R9) | Jayden Daniels QB | Keetz | 329 | +271 |
| 2022 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #74 (R7) | Jalen Hurts QB | Jared Nutter | 370 | +271 |
| 2022 Guardians of the Dynasty League | Rookie draft | #52 (R6) | Geno Smith QB | codyis | 274 | +266 |
| 2023 D3 Dynasty League | Rookie draft | #37 (R4) | Puka Nacua WR | Jared Nutter | 277 | +264 |
| 2015 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #83 (R7) | Cam Newton QB | Josh Bayer | 356 | +262 |
| 2015 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #106 (R9) | Tom Brady QB | The Drake | 328 | +261 |
| 2018 The ShaDynasty League | Rookie draft | #1 (R1) | Saquon Barkley RB | CJ Nutter | 380 | +260 |
| 2021 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #61 (R6) | Josh Allen QB | Talon Cain | 379 | +258 |
| 2024 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) | Dynasty startup | #77 (R7) | Baker Mayfield QB | mharsch75 | 382 | +257 |
| 2024 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) | Rookie draft | #3 (R1) | Jayden Daniels QB | codyis | 365 | +253 |
| 2021 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #72 (R6) | Tom Brady QB | The Drake | 350 | +250 |
| 2011 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #147 (R13) | Matthew Stafford QB | Jordon Nutter | 305 | +250 |
| 2024 D3 Dynasty League | Rookie draft | #4 (R1) | Jayden Daniels QB | Keetz | 356 | +248 |
| 2017 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #92 (R8) | Russell Wilson QB | Bryan Stein | 327 | +246 |
Biggest year-one misses
| Year | Type | Pick | Player | Manager | Y1 pts | vs slot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) | Dynasty startup | #16 (R2) | Tim Tebow TE | the Skeet | 0 | -229 |
| 2020 D3 Dynasty League | Dynasty startup | #1 (R1) | Saquon Barkley RB | Jared Nutter | 15 | -227 |
| 2024 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) | Dynasty startup | #17 (R2) | Todd Gurley RB | codyis | 0 | -224 |
| 2018 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #2 (R1) | Le'Veon Bell RB | Austin Hammett | 0 | -207 |
| 2014 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #1 (R1) | Adrian Peterson RB | Nick Moretti | 9 | -201 |
| 2016 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #8 (R1) | Adrian Peterson RB | The Drake | 8 | -200 |
| 2015 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #16 (R2) | Jordy Nelson WR | Carson Nutter | 0 | -199 |
| 2017 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #1 (R1) | David Johnson RB | the Skeet | 13 | -197 |
| 2016 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #10 (R1) | Keenan Allen WR | Keetz | 12 | -195 |
| 2011 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #5 (R1) | Jamaal Charles RB | Bryan Stein | 13 | -193 |
| 2020 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #2 (R1) | Saquon Barkley RB | Jared Nutter | 15 | -192 |
| 2015 Guardians of the Dynasty League | Dynasty startup | #7 (R1) | Dez Bryant WR | the Skeet | 65 | -185 |
| 2010 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #13 (R2) | Ryan Mathews RB | Bryan Stein | 21 | -183 |
| 2023 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #11 (R1) | Nick Chubb RB | Jordon Nutter | 23 | -182 |
| 2014 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #8 (R1) | Montee Ball RB | Jordon Nutter | 27 | -180 |
| 2021 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #24 (R2) | Michael Thomas WR | The Drake | 0 | -178 |
| 2018 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #21 (R2) | Devonta Freeman RB | Keetz | 8 | -178 |
| 2010 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #23 (R2) | Ryan Grant RB | CJ Nutter | 5 | -178 |
| 2011 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #26 (R3) | Peyton Manning QB | the Skeet | 0 | -175 |
| 2010 The Funky Bunch | Seasonal redraft | #8 (R1) | Shonn Greene RB | drew | 33 | -174 |
Drafters by format
| Format | Manager | Drafts | Graded picks | Per pick | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seasonal redraft | Talon Cain | 10 | 145 | +24.0 | +3,483 |
| Seasonal redraft | Colby Nutter | 7 | 103 | +19.3 | +1,985 |
| Seasonal redraft | Josh Bayer | 11 | 160 | +15.9 | +2,540 |
| Seasonal redraft | Jared Nutter | 7 | 100 | +15.4 | +1,535 |
| Seasonal redraft | Kelly Williams | 3 | 42 | +9.8 | +413 |
| Seasonal redraft | Christian Umbach | 16 | 235 | +5.6 | +1,316 |
| Seasonal redraft | The Drake | 15 | 221 | +3.2 | +703 |
| Seasonal redraft | the Skeet | 15 | 220 | +3.0 | +665 |
| Seasonal redraft | Zemar Loper | 3 | 45 | +0.7 | +32 |
| Seasonal redraft | Nick Moretti | 6 | 87 | +0.2 | +20 |
| Seasonal redraft | Keetz | 16 | 235 | +0.2 | +36 |
| Seasonal redraft | Jordon Nutter | 16 | 235 | -2.9 | -689 |
| Seasonal redraft | Bryan Stein | 16 | 235 | -7.7 | -1,816 |
| Seasonal redraft | Austin Hammett | 6 | 90 | -11.0 | -992 |
| Seasonal redraft | CJ Nutter | 16 | 235 | -11.1 | -2,601 |
| Seasonal redraft | Carson Nutter | 16 | 235 | -11.1 | -2,613 |
| Seasonal redraft | Mark Garner | 3 | 45 | -17.9 | -806 |
| Seasonal redraft | Little Mark | 1 | 15 | -20.0 | -300 |
| Seasonal redraft | Anthony Oliver | 4 | 60 | -20.8 | -1,246 |
| Seasonal redraft | Raymond | 1 | 15 | -37.6 | -564 |
| Rookie draft | Nick Bayer | 2 | 11 | +20.3 | +224 |
| Rookie draft | Charles Hartz | 6 | 21 | +20.3 | +426 |
| Rookie draft | Lorenz | 6 | 33 | +17.7 | +585 |
| Rookie draft | Tommarello | 3 | 16 | +12.6 | +202 |
| Rookie draft | Talon Cain | 14 | 58 | +11.9 | +691 |
| Rookie draft | Eric Harper | 6 | 26 | +8.9 | +230 |
| Rookie draft | Jared Nutter | 14 | 72 | +5.4 | +392 |
| Rookie draft | Jordon Nutter | 22 | 142 | +4.3 | +618 |
| Rookie draft | Carson Nutter | 25 | 113 | +4.2 | +477 |
| Rookie draft | Keetz | 15 | 70 | +1.5 | +107 |
| Rookie draft | Josh Bayer | 25 | 158 | +0.7 | +114 |
| Rookie draft | the Skeet | 25 | 120 | -2.8 | -330 |
| Rookie draft | Derek Glover | 15 | 69 | -4.4 | -301 |
| Rookie draft | Bryan Stein | 25 | 173 | -4.6 | -794 |
| Rookie draft | Kelly Williams | 9 | 42 | -4.7 | -199 |
| Rookie draft | CJ Nutter | 25 | 137 | -6.9 | -939 |
| Rookie draft | Austin Hammett | 3 | 14 | -10.5 | -147 |
| Rookie draft | Nick Moretti | 10 | 42 | -13.0 | -545 |
| Rookie draft | CamuelLJackson (unidentified) | 5 | 26 | -15.7 | -409 |
| Rookie draft | Zemar Loper | 4 | 21 | -20.4 | -427 |
| Rookie draft | Matt Presto | 2 | 14 | -22.6 | -317 |
| Rookie draft | Garrett Hepner | 2 | 10 | -24.5 | -245 |
| Dynasty startup | Derek Glover | 1 | 30 | +24.9 | +747 |
| Dynasty startup | Keetz | 1 | 35 | +10.0 | +351 |
| Dynasty startup | Eric Harper | 1 | 34 | +8.9 | +303 |
| Dynasty startup | Bryan Stein | 3 | 95 | +6.0 | +568 |
| Dynasty startup | the Skeet | 3 | 91 | +5.7 | +522 |
| Dynasty startup | Josh Bayer | 3 | 92 | +5.5 | +511 |
| Dynasty startup | Matt Durbin | 1 | 25 | +2.3 | +58 |
| Dynasty startup | Nick Bayer | 1 | 30 | +0.9 | +27 |
| Dynasty startup | Kelly Williams | 2 | 63 | -0.4 | -26 |
| Dynasty startup | Mike Marks | 1 | 27 | -3.1 | -85 |
| Dynasty startup | Zemar Loper | 1 | 27 | -3.3 | -90 |
| Dynasty startup | Carson Nutter | 3 | 89 | -4.2 | -375 |
| Dynasty startup | CJ Nutter | 3 | 92 | -6.2 | -575 |
| Dynasty startup | Colby Nutter | 1 | 30 | -6.4 | -192 |
| Dynasty startup | Charles Hartz | 1 | 35 | -6.8 | -240 |
| Dynasty startup | Jordon Nutter | 2 | 65 | -11.1 | -721 |
| Dynasty startup | Talon Cain | 2 | 62 | -13.4 | -833 |
| Dynasty startup | Jared Nutter | 1 | 35 | -16.9 | -592 |
| Dynasty startup | The Drake | 1 | 27 | -23.6 | -638 |
What the grade means. Teams are ranked only against teams in the same draft, using average year-one production above or below the historical expectation for that slot and draft type. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Top 20% earns A, then B/C/D/F in equal bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Open a draft for every manager’s complete report card and picks. Imports receive no grade; recent picks without a completed scoring season say “Too early.” This is a report on immediate fantasy production, not a claim about long-term dynasty value.