2024 rookie draft board

PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) · 60 picks · 5 rounds · 11 teams · season 2024 · all drafts · Manager report cards
Speed
Pick 0 of 60
RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.
RD
the Skeet
codyis
Josh Bayer
NOB42
mharsch75
Carson Nutter
Nick Bayer
Colby Nutter
Bryan Stein
CJ Nutter
Derek Glover
1
#1 CalebCHI QB
Williams
#4 MalikNYG WR
Nabers
#10 JonathonCAR RB
Brooks
#2 MarvinARI WR
Harrison
#3 JaydenWAS QB
Daniels
#5 RomeCHI WR
Odunze
#6 DrakeNE QB
Maye
#12 LaddLAC WR
McConkey
#7 J.J.MIN QB
McCarthy
#8 XavierKC WR
Worthy
#9 BrockLV TE
Bowers
#11 BrianJAX WR
Thomas
No selection
No selection
No selection
2
#19 RickySF WR
Pearsall
No selection
#14 MichaelATL QB
Penix
#21 JaylenMIA RB
Wright
#16 TreyARI RB
Benson
#17 BoDEN QB
Nix
#15 AdonaiIND WR
Mitchell
#18 BlakeLAR RB
Corum
#23 Ja'LynnNE WR
Polk
#24 RomanPIT WR
Wilson
No selection
No selection
#13 KeonBUF WR
Coleman
#20 XavierCAR WR
Legette
#22 MalachiNYJ WR
Corley
No selection
3
No selection
No selection
#26 TroyDEN WR
Franklin
#30 Ja'TavionCAR TE
Sanders
#28 BenWAS TE
Sinnott
#36 BuckyTB RB
Irving
#35 BrendenLAC WR
Rice
No selection
#33 KimaniLAC RB
Vidal
#32 JalenTB WR
McMillan
No selection
#25 JermaineCIN WR
Burton
#29 MarShawnGB RB
Lloyd
#31 LukeWAS WR
McCaffrey
#34 RayBUF RB
Davis
#27 JavonNE WR
Baker
4
No selection
No selection
#38 AudricDEN RB
Estime
#46 IsaacSF RB
Guerendo
No selection
#41 SpencerNO QB
Rattler
#45 WillPHI RB
Shipley
#47 TheoNYG TE
Johnson
#48 RasheenBAL RB
Ali
No selection
#39 TyroneNYG RB
Tracy
#40 JohnnyPHI WR
Wilson
#44 DevontezBAL WR
Walker
No selection
#37 MalikMIA WR
Washington
#43 BraelonNYJ RB
Allen
#42 DylanLV RB
Laube
No selection
5
No selection
No selection
#53 AiniasPHI WR
Smith
#52 JalenCAR WR
Coker
#56 JaheimNE TE
Bell
#50 JaredKC TE
Wiley
#51 JacobSF WR
Cowing
#57 Tom QB
Brady
No selection
#60 MichaelGB QB
Pratt
No selection
#49 JordanNYJ QB
Travis
#55 JamariCLE WR
Thrash
#59 CodySF RB
Schrader
#54 ErickCIN TE
All
#58 CadeHOU TE
Stover
No selection
Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

codyis A

The Pittsburgh Wheelers · 2 picks · 2 graded

Average vs slot: +143.8 points · total +287.5 ÷ 2 graded picks · rank 1 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Jayden Daniels (#3, +252.6). Worst pick: Marvin Harrison (#2, +35.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#2 / R1Marvin Harrison WRNick Bayer · traded pick151.9116.9+35.0
#3 / R1Jayden Daniels QBZer · traded pick364.8112.3+252.6

Colby Nutter A

TheBeans69 · 2 picks · 2 graded

Average vs slot: +117.4 points · total +234.8 ÷ 2 graded picks · rank 2 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Brian Thomas (#11, +189.1). Worst pick: Jalen McMillan (#32, +45.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#11 / R1Brian Thomas WRJosh Bayer · traded pick257.968.8+189.1
#32 / R3Jalen McMillan WRcodyis · traded pick58.713.0+45.7

Nick Bayer B

Canton Condors · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +41.1 points · total +246.4 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 3 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Brock Bowers (#9, +170.9). Worst pick: Kimani Vidal (#33, -13.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#9 / R1Brock Bowers TEthe Skeet · traded pick250.980.0+170.9
#33 / R3Kimani Vidal RBthe Skeet · traded pick0.013.6-13.6
#39 / R4Tyrone Tracy RBZer · traded pick128.112.2+115.9
#40 / R4Johnny Wilson WRDerek Glover · traded pick0.012.0-12.0
#44 / R4Devontez Walker WRcodyis · traded pick0.07.6-7.6
#60 / R5Michael Pratt QBBryan Stein · traded pick0.07.2-7.2

NOB42 B

The Amish · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: +37.2 points · total +297.4 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 4 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Bucky Irving (#36, +195.5). Worst pick: Trey Benson (#16, -42.9).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#6 / R1Drake Maye QBNOB4263.2101.2-38.0
#12 / R1Ladd McConkey WRBryan Stein · traded pick194.863.5+131.3
#16 / R2Trey Benson RBDerek Glover · traded pick0.042.9-42.9
#17 / R2Bo Nix QBmharsch75 · traded pick121.940.1+81.7
#28 / R3Ben Sinnott TEDerek Glover · traded pick0.014.4-14.4
#36 / R3Bucky Irving RBBryan Stein · traded pick208.713.2+195.5
#52 / R5Jalen Coker WRDerek Glover · traded pick0.07.3-7.3
#56 / R5Jaheim Bell TEcodyis · traded pick0.08.7-8.7

the Skeet C

johndennis · 4 picks · 4 graded

Average vs slot: +8.7 points · total +34.9 ÷ 4 graded picks · rank 6 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Caleb Williams (#1, +70.7). Worst pick: Jonathon Brooks (#10, -74.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#1 / R1Caleb Williams QBCarson Nutter · traded pick191.3120.6+70.7
#4 / R1Malik Nabers WRDerek Glover · traded pick177.4108.3+69.1
#10 / R1Jonathon Brooks RBCJ Nutter · traded pick-0.373.9-74.2
#19 / R2Ricky Pearsall WRColby Nutter · traded pick1.532.3-30.8

Bryan Stein D

steinb11 · 7 picks · 7 graded

Average vs slot: -4.8 points · total -33.7 ÷ 7 graded picks · rank 7 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Xavier Legette (#20, +14.1). Worst pick: Keon Coleman (#13, -26.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#13 / R2Keon Coleman WRCarson Nutter · traded pick32.258.4-26.2
#20 / R2Xavier Legette WRcodyis · traded pick43.929.8+14.1
#37 / R4Malik Washington WRCarson Nutter · traded pick0.012.7-12.7
#43 / R4Braelon Allen RBColby Nutter · traded pick21.59.3+12.2
#49 / R5Jordan Travis QBCarson Nutter · traded pick0.06.1-6.1
#55 / R5Jamari Thrash WRColby Nutter · traded pick0.08.3-8.3
#59 / R5Cody Schrader RBJosh Bayer · traded pick0.06.6-6.6

CJ Nutter D

Homicidal Hobbits · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: -14.0 points · total -111.6 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 8 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Erick All (#54, -7.7). Worst pick: Malachi Corley (#22, -26.9).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#22 / R2Malachi Corley WRCJ Nutter0.026.9-26.9
#25 / R3Jermaine Burton WRCarson Nutter · traded pick0.017.4-17.4
#29 / R3MarShawn Lloyd RBmharsch75 · traded pick0.014.3-14.3
#31 / R3Luke McCaffrey WRColby Nutter · traded pick0.013.4-13.4
#34 / R3Ray Davis RBCJ Nutter0.012.7-12.7
#42 / R4Dylan Laube RBNOB42 · traded pick0.010.5-10.5
#54 / R5Erick All TENOB42 · traded pick0.07.7-7.7
#58 / R5Cade Stover TECJ Nutter0.08.7-8.7

Derek Glover F

Derek Henry · 1 picks · 1 graded

Average vs slot: -15.8 points · total -15.8 ÷ 1 graded picks · rank 9 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Javon Baker (#27, -15.8). Worst pick: Javon Baker (#27, -15.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#27 / R3Javon Baker WRZer · traded pick0.015.8-15.8

Josh Bayer F

Won’t You Be My Nabers · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: -20.0 points · total -160.4 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 10 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Isaac Guerendo (#46, +29.6). Worst pick: Rome Odunze (#5, -75.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#5 / R1Rome Odunze WRmharsch75 · traded pick28.8104.5-75.7
#14 / R2Michael Penix QBNick Bayer · traded pick0.052.1-52.1
#21 / R2Jaylen Wright RBthe Skeet · traded pick0.028.6-28.6
#26 / R3Troy Franklin WRNick Bayer · traded pick0.016.4-16.4
#30 / R3Ja'Tavion Sanders TENOB42 · traded pick7.912.9-5.0
#38 / R4Audric Estime RBNick Bayer · traded pick7.012.2-5.2
#46 / R4Isaac Guerendo RBCJ Nutter · traded pick38.38.7+29.6
#53 / R5Ainias Smith WRmharsch75 · traded pick0.07.0-7.0

mharsch75 F

The Shitbag Express · 11 picks · 11 graded

Average vs slot: -21.8 points · total -240.0 ÷ 11 graded picks · rank 11 of 11 graded teams.

Best pick: Theo Johnson (#47, -5.3). Worst pick: J.J. McCarthy (#7, -96.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#7 / R1J.J. McCarthy QBColby Nutter · traded pick0.096.8-96.8
#15 / R2Adonai Mitchell WRZer · traded pick6.547.5-41.0
#18 / R2Blake Corum RBNOB42 · traded pick0.036.5-36.5
#35 / R3Brenden Rice WRJosh Bayer · traded pick0.013.2-13.2
#41 / R4Spencer Rattler QBmharsch750.011.5-11.5
#45 / R4Will Shipley RBthe Skeet · traded pick0.08.2-8.2
#47 / R4Theo Johnson TEJosh Bayer · traded pick2.37.6-5.3
#48 / R4Rasheen Ali RBBryan Stein · traded pick0.06.8-6.8
#50 / R5Jared Wiley TENick Bayer · traded pick0.05.8-5.8
#51 / R5Jacob Cowing WRZer · traded pick0.05.8-5.8
#57 / R5Tom Brady QBthe Skeet · traded pick0.09.2-9.2