Manager directoryCareer profile

Colby Nutter

10 seasons across 3 leagues
nfl 12269428 mfl Colby Nutter sleeper TheBeans69
0
championships
59–76
overall record
.437
win rate
10
seasons
15,515
points for
Seasonal 35–59 over 7 Dynasty 24–17 over 3 combined is the headline; the split is what it is made of
The archive read

What the numbers say

Colby Nutter's story is one of persistence across 10 seasons and 3 leagues. The 59–76 overall record and .437 win rate show the full shape of the career while the first championship remains the missing chapter.

Championship eraStill chasing the first oneThe open storyline
Best homePADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League).643 win rate
Most familiar foeCarson Nutter4–9 over 13 games
Most points, one season2,234 pointsPADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2025

Wooden spoons 1

2025
2025 Beans 4–10 · 14 teams

Achievements 4

Best record, one season
11–3 — PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2025
Most points, one season
2,234 points — PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2025
Best record, no title ×2
PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) · The Funky Bunch
Founding member
In PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) from its first season, 2024
Every badge is computed from the archive, never written by hand. Records are scoped to a league — a 14-team redraft season and a 10-team dynasty season are not competing for the same record — and ties are shared, not broken. MFL titles come from the league's rendered playoff bracket, since its export API names no winner.

The ones you kept

Player relationships

Arizona Cardinals is the longest-running thread in this manager's lineup history. Bar length is seasons started—not roster churn or bench time.

01
Arizona CardinalsDef · 2016, 2024–2025
3 yrs

Luck

Kindest schedule+14.22024 · PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League)
Toughest break-26.82019 · The Funky Bunch

Over time, the breaks have nearly evened out. Luck here means actual win rate minus the rate those same scores would earn against every team each week.

2019
-26.8The Funky Bunch
2024
+14.2PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League)
2024
-11.1The Funky Bunch
2023
+10.1The Funky Bunch
2025
+9.4PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League)
2025
-7.4The Funky Bunch
2016
+7.3Guardians of the Dynasty League
2018
-4.4The Funky Bunch

The Funky Bunch

redraft nfl 2016–2025
0
championships
35–59
record
.372
win rate
7
seasons
10,021
points for

Season by season

YearTeamRecordPFPAFinish
2016 Cenanation 7–6 1,550.71,424.7 5th
2017 Cenanation 4–9 1,247.51,382.8 10th
2018 Cenanation 5–8 1,457.51,585.8 9th
2019 Skeet Skeet 2–11 1,5001,632.3 11th
2023 Beans 10–4 1,6641,387.5 2nd
2024 Beans 3–11 1,291.41,528.5 13th
2025 Beans 4–10 1,309.71,499.3 14th

Head to head

OpponentW–LGamesDiff
Carson Nutter 4–9 13 -100
Keetz 4–7 11 -97
The Drake 3–6 9 -46
Bryan Stein 4–5 9 -55
CJ Nutter 1–8 9 -100
Jordon Nutter 4–5 9 +106
Christian Umbach 4–4 8 -3
Josh Bayer 4–4 8 -13
the Skeet 4–3 7 +100
Talon Cain 2–4 6 -48
Jared Nutter 0–6 6 -168
Jonathan 2–2 4 -57
Zemar Loper 2–1 3 +72
Nick Moretti 2–1 3 +55

Best & worst weeks

WhenOpponentScore
best2018 wk5Jordon Nutter186.8 – 80.3
best2023 wk3Talon Cain169.1 – 102.8
best2016 wk10Josh Bayer165.5 – 96.6
worst2025 wk17Jordon Nutter56.1 – 60.1
worst2024 wk7Keetz56.3 – 71.4
worst2025 wk14Jared Nutter59.1 – 121.2
54
waiver moves
0
trades

PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League)

dynasty sleeper 2024–2025
0
championships
18–10
record
.643
win rate
2
seasons
4,093
points for

Season by season

YearTeamRecordPFPAFinish
2024 TheBeans69 7–7 1,858.21,852.8 —
2025 TheBeans69 11–3 2,234.31,875.4 —

Head to head

OpponentW–LGamesDiff
CJ Nutter 3–2 5 +72
Derek Glover 2–2 4 +43
Carson Nutter 4–0 4 +106
Bryan Stein 3–0 3 +102
Zer 2–1 3 +72
NOB42 2–1 3 +4
Josh Bayer 1–2 3 -29
mharsch75 1–1 2 -30
the Skeet 0–2 2 -23
Nick Bayer 2–0 2 +18
codyis 1–1 2 -19

Best & worst weeks

WhenOpponentScore
best2025 wk8Zer207.3 – 154.8
best2025 wk2CJ Nutter189.5 – 98.8
best2025 wk12Carson Nutter188.1 – 130.2
worst2024 wk4mharsch7596.9 – 149.4
worst2025 wk17Zer104.6 – 84.6
worst2024 wk10Carson Nutter110.1 – 102
8
trades

Guardians of the Dynasty League

dynasty mfl 2016–2016
0
championships
6–7
record
.462
win rate
1
season
1,402
points for

Season by season

YearTeamRecordPFPAFinish
2016 The LA Sweat 6–7 1,401.71,285.4 —
MFL seasons record no final placing, so Finish is blank there. The champion comes from the league's playoff bracket and appears in the case above.

Head to head

OpponentW–LGamesDiff
Talon Cain 1–1 2 +4
Jordon Nutter 2–0 2 +25
Matt Presto 1–1 2 +108
Zemar Loper 0–1 1 -17
Bryan Stein 1–0 1 +10
Carson Nutter 0–1 1 -1
the Skeet 0–1 1 -4
Kelly Williams 0–1 1 -24
Josh Bayer 1–0 1 +56
CJ Nutter 0–1 1 -41

Best & worst weeks

WhenOpponentScore
best2016 wk10Josh Bayer142.5 – 86.3
best2016 wk4Matt Presto130.5 – 0
best2016 wk1Talon Cain127.7 – 103
worst2016 wk11CJ Nutter79.4 – 120.5
worst2016 wk9Kelly Williams83.7 – 107.8
worst2016 wk2Zemar Loper84 – 100.5
5
trades
1
draft-capital years

Longest-tenured players

PlayerSeasons heldStartsPointsYears
Ben Roethlisberger QB 111 2162016
A.J. Green WR 110 1862016
Tom Brady QB 18 1792016
LeGarrette Blount RB 110 1522016
Christine Michael RB 18 1072016
Jeremy Maclin WR 18 792016
Mason Crosby PK 110 772016
Ryan Mathews RB 16 712016
Zach Ertz TE 18 712016
Arizona Cardinals Def 18 492016
Graham Gano PK 13 292016
Anquan Boldin WR 12 282016
Counted over the MFL era only. The tenure itself is not bounded by it — MFL and Sleeper players are matched on shared external ids, so a player can be followed across the platform change.

Draft capital & cycle

YearPicks heldAcquiredRecordLean
2016 5006-7 win-now
“Lean” is interpretive: 3+ acquired picks reads as building, zero as win-now. A heuristic, not a claim.

Trades

dynasty picks outnumber players — dynasty trading is mostly pick trading
13
trades
6
partners
8 / 12
players out / in
16 / 7
picks out / in
2016–2026
span
Assets out and in are not meant to balance. Colby Nutter sent 24 pieces and took back 19: 5 trades packaged more than came back, 1 did the reverse, 7 were even by count. Packaging depth into one better asset is a strategy, not an error — and a count says nothing about value, which is what grading will add.

Trade grades

-27
total, 3-season
—
per trade (needs 5)
1/4
trades won
A trade is worth what it PRODUCED, measured against a league-average starter at that position — Cam's call, and the stricter option: it asks "did he beat a typical starter", not "did he beat your bench". A pick is graded as the player it actually became, never a value curve. The headline horizon is three seasons. Grades are exactly equal and opposite: the measured production edge is zero-sum. Both managers may still improve their rosters or meet different needs. 9 of 13 trades are partial — at least one leg is a pick that could not be resolved — and are excluded from these totals rather than counted as zero.

Trade partners

PartnerTradesAssets outAssets in
CJ Nutter 686
Matt Presto 399
Nick Bayer 111
Carson Nutter 121
the Skeet 111
Bryan Stein 131

Every trade

DateLeagueWith GaveGotAssetsGrade
2026-05-03 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) Nick Bayer 2026 round 3 via TheBeans69 Chig Okonkwo TE 2 partial
2026-05-01 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) Carson Nutter 2026 round 1 via TheBeans692027 round 1 via TheBeans69 2026 round 1 via Canton Condors 3 partial
2025-04-30 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) CJ Nutter 2025 round 4 via TheBeans692026 round 2 via TheBeans69 Anthony Richardson QB 3 partial
2024-11-18 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) CJ Nutter Devaughn Vele WR Tommy DeVito QB 2 +0
2024-11-09 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) CJ Nutter Anthony Richardson QB Kareem Hunt RB 2 +9
2024-11-09 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) CJ Nutter Jaylen Waddle WR2025 round 2 via TheBeans69 Tua Tagovailoa QB 3 partial
2024-11-03 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) the Skeet 2025 round 3 via TheBeans69 Daniel Jones QB 2 partial
2024-05-24 PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) Bryan Stein 2024 round 4 via cnutt2024 round 5 via cnutt2024 round 5 via TheBeans69 2025 round 3 via steinb11 4 partial
2016-08-23 Guardians of the Dynasty League Matt Presto Matt Ryan QBAmeer Abdullah RBCorey Brown WRCoby Fleener TE 2017 round 1 via The LA Sweat2017 round 2 via The LA Sweat2017 round 5 via The LA Sweat2018 round 1 via The LA Sweat2018 round 5 via The LA Sweat 9 partial
2016-08-12 Guardians of the Dynasty League Matt Presto 2017 round 1 via The LA Sweat2017 round 2 via The LA Sweat2018 round 1 via The LA Sweat Matt Ryan QBAmeer Abdullah RBCoby Fleener TE 6 partial
2016-08-12 Guardians of the Dynasty League Matt Presto 2017 round 5 via The LA Sweat2018 round 5 via The LA Sweat Corey Brown WR 3 partial
2016-03-23 Guardians of the Dynasty League CJ Nutter 2016 round 1.04 Tyler Lockett WR 2 -14
2016-03-11 Guardians of the Dynasty League CJ Nutter Tyrod Taylor QB Ryan Mathews RB 2 -21
Trades follow the person, not the account — Colby Nutter is matched across every handle they hold on both platforms. Picks show the franchise they originated from where it is known. Resolved picks are valued as the players they became. Fully resolved trades feed the totals above; view trade evidence for original assets, resolved picks, timing, and horizons.

Off the wire 28

Each scored start is credited once, after its recorded acquisition and before the next recorded ownership change. Uncertain ordering and identities receive no wire credit. Gaps in historical transaction capture can still limit the totals. Attribution and coverage.

Seasonal

redraft Recorded order: 15th of 19
410
points landed
10
pickups that started
44
starts
PlayerLeagueSeason StartsPointsvs starter
Jared Cook TE The Funky Bunch 2017 16 126 -34
Sam Howell QB The Funky Bunch 2023 6 104 +1
Devin Singletary RB The Funky Bunch 2025 5 50 -18
Matthew Stafford QB The Funky Bunch 2025 3 49 -2
Theo Johnson TE The Funky Bunch 2025 5 27 -24
Ryan Tannehill QB The Funky Bunch 2016 1 16 -2
Matt Breida RB The Funky Bunch 2023 2 16 -9
Devaughn Vele WR The Funky Bunch 2024 2 9 -17
Dyami Brown WR The Funky Bunch 2025 2 6 -17
Andrei Iosivas WR The Funky Bunch 2024 2 6 -20
Scored over the season it was claimed in — the roster resets afterwards.

Dynasty

dynasty Recorded order: 17th of 27
404
points landed
18
pickups that started
55
starts
20
seasons with starts
PlayerLeagueSeason Seasons with starts StartsPointsvs starter
Los Angeles Rams DEF PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 2 →2025 15 151 +34
Arizona Cardinals DEF PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 2 →2025 10 65 -20
Jack Doyle TE Guardians of the Dynasty League 2016 1 5 28 -25
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine WR PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 3 27 -13
Josh Johnson QB PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2025 1 2 26 -7
Adam Humphries WR Guardians of the Dynasty League 2016 1 3 24 -16
Vernon Davis TE Guardians of the Dynasty League 2016 1 2 22 +0
Andy Borregales K PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2025 1 2 14 -4
Brayden Narveson K PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 1 10 +2
Las Vegas Raiders DEF PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 3 9 -17
Atlanta Falcons DEF PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 1 7 -2
Miami Dolphins DEF Guardians of the Dynasty League 2016 1 1 6 -1
Dorian Thompson-Robinson QB PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 2 6 -29
David Moore WR PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 1 5 -9
Devaughn Vele WR PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2024 1 1 3 -10
Luke Willson TE Guardians of the Dynasty League 2016 1 1 2 -9
Jacob Tamme TE Guardians of the Dynasty League 2016 1 1 1 -9
Riley Leonard QB PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) 2025 1 1 0 -17
Scored over every season it kept starting, uncapped. Seasons with starts counts attributed seasons, not proven continuous ownership.
A productive pickup record includes attributed starts; unproductive claims are excluded from that denominator. Trade returns are graded separately on the trades board. Full board: the waiver wire.
The combined career total is a deliberate choice, and so is the split beneath it. Redraft and dynasty are genuinely different games, so the totals are always shown broken down as well as merged — the headline is the career, the split is what it is made of. Format is derived from league structure (future draft picks, taxi squad, roster size), never from the league name.

Identity: NFL.com resolves person → userId → teamId per season; MFL resolves person → real owner name → franchiseId. Both from people.seed.json. Nothing is matched on a display name.