2017 rookie draft board

Guardians of the Dynasty League · 60 picks · 5 rounds · 12 teams · season 2017 · all drafts · Manager report cards
Speed
Pick 0 of 60
RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.
RD
CJ Nutter
Jordon Nutter
Matt Presto
Carson Nutter
Anthony Oliver
Zemar Loper
Bryan Stein
Talon Cain
the Skeet
Josh Bayer
Austin Hammett
Kelly Williams
1
#1 CoreyTEN WR
Davis
#2 JoeCIN RB
Mixon
#3 JohnCIN WR
Ross
#7 SamajeWAS RB
Perine
#8 O.J.TBB TE
Howard
#4 ChristianCAR RB
McCaffrey
#10 DeshaunHOU QB
Watson
#12 DavidCLE TE
Njoku
#5 LeonardJAC RB
Fournette
#6 DalvinMIN RB
Cook
#9 MikeLAC WR
Williams
#11 DeShoneCLE QB
Kizer
No selection
No selection
No selection
No selection
2
#24 MarlonIND RB
Mack
No selection
#13 MarshawnSEA RB
Lynch
No selection
#15 EvanNYG TE
Engram
#18 ZayBUF WR
Jones
#16 MitchellCHI QB
Trubisky
#21 KareemKCC RB
Hunt
No selection
#14 PatrickKCC QB
Mahomes
#22 ChrisTBB WR
Godwin
#23 JoeSFO RB
Williams
#17 AlvinNOS RB
Kamara
#19 CurtisCAR WR
Samuel
#20 JuJuPIT WR
Smith-Schuster
3
#31 KennyDET WR
Golladay
#34 TaywanTEN WR
Taylor
#25 JamesPIT RB
Conner
No selection
#29 RexCIN RB
Burkhead
#30 JoshLAR WR
Reynolds
#33 CarlosDEN WR
Henderson
#35 CooperLAR WR
Kupp
#26 D'OntaHOU RB
Foreman
#28 GeraldLAR TE
Everett
#36 ChadARI WR
Williams
#27 JamaalGBP RB
Williams
No selection
#32 WayneNYG RB
Gallman
4
#45 BenNOS TE
Watson
#38 AmaraSEA WR
Darboh
#46 ErikIND TE
Swoope
#37 RyanDAL WR
Switzer
#47 JakeDEN TE
Butt
No selection
#41 ArDariusNYJ WR
Stewart
#42 DonnelPHI RB
Pumphrey
No selection
#48 ArtavisLAC WR
Scott
#40 AaronGBP RB
Jones
#39 JeremySFO RB
McNichols
#43 JordanNYJ TE
Leggett
#44 AdamCHI TE
Shaheen
5
No selection
#50 ElijahNYJ RB
McGuire
#49 NathanBUF QB
Peterman
#58 MinnesotaMIN Def
Vikings
No selection
#53 BrockDEN QB
Osweiler
#54 CoreyPHI RB
Clement
#55 JoshCIN WR
Malone
#51 DedeJAC WR
Westbrook
#56 IshmaelFA WR
Zamora
#57 TarikCHI RB
Cohen
#60 ElijahOAK RB
Hood
#52 JonnuTEN TE
Smith
No selection
#59 JoshuaPIT QB
Dobbs
No selection
Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

Josh Bayer A

Ya Down With ODB? · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: +32.1 points · total +96.4 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 1 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Alvin Kamara (#17, +124.5). Worst pick: Jamaal Williams (#27, -15.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#17 / R2Alvin Kamara RBNot recorded164.640.1+124.5
#27 / R3Jamaal Williams RBNot recorded0.015.8-15.8
#39 / R4Jeremy McNichols RBNot recorded0.012.2-12.2

Anthony Oliver A

The Other Black Guy in this League · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: +21.5 points · total +107.7 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Leonard Fournette (#5, +70.2). Worst pick: ArDarius Stewart (#41, -11.5).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#5 / R1Leonard Fournette RBNot recorded174.7104.5+70.2
#15 / R2Evan Engram TENot recorded76.247.5+28.7
#29 / R3Rex Burkhead RBNot recorded41.614.3+27.3
#41 / R4ArDarius Stewart WRNot recorded0.011.5-11.5
#53 / R5Brock Osweiler QBNot recorded0.07.0-7.0

Carson Nutter B

Straight Outta Bikini Bottom · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: +12.4 points · total +37.3 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Christian McCaffrey (#4, +54.8). Worst pick: David Njoku (#12, -35.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#4 / R1Christian McCaffrey RBNot recorded163.1108.3+54.8
#10 / R1Deshaun Watson QBNot recorded91.673.9+17.7
#12 / R1David Njoku TENot recorded28.263.5-35.3

Talon Cain B

The Medulla Oblongata · 4 picks · 4 graded

Average vs slot: +11.2 points · total +44.9 ÷ 4 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: DeShone Kizer (#11, +57.2). Worst pick: Elijah Hood (#60, -7.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#11 / R1DeShone Kizer QBNot recorded126.068.8+57.2
#35 / R3Cooper Kupp WRNot recorded14.813.2+1.6
#48 / R4Artavis Scott WRNot recorded0.06.8-6.8
#60 / R5Elijah Hood RBNot recorded0.07.2-7.2

Kelly Williams C

No Bad JuJu · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: +8.1 points · total +24.3 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: JuJu Smith-Schuster (#20, +37.6). Worst pick: Adam Shaheen (#44, -7.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#20 / R2JuJu Smith-Schuster WRNot recorded67.429.8+37.6
#32 / R3Wayne Gallman RBNot recorded7.313.0-5.7
#44 / R4Adam Shaheen TENot recorded0.07.6-7.6

Bryan Stein C

Frosted Covered Mini Wheatons · 7 picks · 7 graded

Average vs slot: +5.0 points · total +34.9 ÷ 7 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Kareem Hunt (#21, +128.5). Worst pick: Mike Williams (#9, -80.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#9 / R1Mike Williams WRNot recorded0.080.0-80.0
#16 / R2Mitchell Trubisky QBNot recorded57.842.9+14.9
#21 / R2Kareem Hunt RBNot recorded157.128.6+128.5
#33 / R3Carlos Henderson WRNot recorded0.013.6-13.6
#51 / R5Dede Westbrook WRNot recorded0.05.8-5.8
#56 / R5Ishmael Zamora WRNot recorded0.08.7-8.7
#57 / R5Tarik Cohen RBNot recorded8.89.2-0.4

Jordon Nutter C

Mr. Peanutbutter's House · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -12.0 points · total -60.2 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 7 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Elijah McGuire (#50, -3.6). Worst pick: Joe Mixon (#2, -22.9).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#2 / R1Joe Mixon RBNot recorded94.0116.9-22.9
#34 / R3Taywan Taylor WRNot recorded0.012.7-12.7
#38 / R4Amara Darboh WRNot recorded0.012.2-12.2
#46 / R4Erik Swoope TENot recorded0.08.7-8.7
#50 / R5Elijah McGuire RBNot recorded2.25.8-3.6

Austin Hammett D

The Tosche Station Power Converters · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: -16.1 points · total -48.2 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Joshua Dobbs (#59, -6.6). Worst pick: Curtis Samuel (#19, -32.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#19 / R2Curtis Samuel WRNot recorded0.032.3-32.3
#43 / R4Jordan Leggett TENot recorded0.09.3-9.3
#59 / R5Joshua Dobbs QBNot recorded0.06.6-6.6

the Skeet D

Not The Beans · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: -17.4 points · total -139.4 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 9 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Aaron Jones (#40, +13.9). Worst pick: Patrick Mahomes (#14, -52.1).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#14 / R2Patrick Mahomes QBNot recorded0.052.1-52.1
#22 / R2Chris Godwin WRNot recorded0.026.9-26.9
#23 / R2Joe Williams RBNot recorded0.023.1-23.1
#26 / R3D'Onta Foreman RBNot recorded0.016.4-16.4
#28 / R3Gerald Everett TENot recorded0.014.4-14.4
#36 / R3Chad Williams WRNot recorded0.013.2-13.2
#40 / R4Aaron Jones RBNot recorded25.912.0+13.9
#52 / R5Jonnu Smith TENot recorded0.07.3-7.3

Zemar Loper F

No Longer The Only Black Guy In This League · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: -18.6 points · total -111.7 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 10 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Corey Clement (#54, -7.7). Worst pick: Zay Jones (#18, -36.5).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#6 / R1Dalvin Cook RBNot recorded65.4101.2-35.8
#18 / R2Zay Jones WRNot recorded0.036.5-36.5
#30 / R3Josh Reynolds WRNot recorded0.012.9-12.9
#42 / R4Donnel Pumphrey RBNot recorded0.010.5-10.5
#54 / R5Corey Clement RBNot recorded0.07.7-7.7
#55 / R5Josh Malone WRNot recorded0.08.3-8.3

Matt Presto F

The Morning Show Mafia · 9 picks · 9 graded

Average vs slot: -26.2 points · total -236.0 ÷ 9 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Marshawn Lynch (#13, +57.1). Worst pick: John Ross (#3, -112.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#3 / R1John Ross WRNot recorded0.0112.3-112.3
#7 / R1Samaje Perine RBNot recorded32.996.8-63.9
#8 / R1O.J. Howard TENot recorded3.686.1-82.5
#13 / R2Marshawn Lynch RBNot recorded115.558.4+57.1
#25 / R3James Conner RBNot recorded0.017.4-17.4
#37 / R4Ryan Switzer WRNot recorded0.012.7-12.7
#47 / R4Jake Butt TENot recorded0.07.6-7.6
#49 / R5Nathan Peterman QBNot recorded0.06.1-6.1
#58 / R5Minnesota Vikings DefNot recorded18.08.7+9.3

CJ Nutter F

Finn's Finishers · 4 picks · 4 graded

Average vs slot: -38.3 points · total -153.1 ÷ 4 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Ben Watson (#45, +0.4). Worst pick: Corey Davis (#1, -120.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#1 / R1Corey Davis WRNot recorded0.0120.6-120.6
#24 / R2Marlon Mack RBNot recorded0.019.6-19.6
#31 / R3Kenny Golladay WRNot recorded0.013.4-13.4
#45 / R4Ben Watson TENot recorded8.68.2+0.4