2012 draft board

The Funky Bunch · 180 picks · 15 rounds · 12 teams · season 2012 · all drafts · Manager report cards
Speed
Pick 0 of 180
RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.
RD
Chad
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

Chad A

The Leatherchests · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: +7.3 points · total +109.5 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 1 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Dez Bryant (#68, +92.2). Worst pick: Roy Helu (#101, -72.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#5 / R1LeSean McCoy RBNot recorded134.7206.2-71.5
#20 / R2Adrian Peterson RBNot recorded275.3188.5+86.8
#29 / R3Andre Johnson WRNot recorded169.7165.5+4.2
#44 / R4Julio Jones WRNot recorded156.5131.6+24.9
#53 / R5Tony Romo QBNot recorded109.4128.6-19.2
#68 / R6Dez Bryant WRNot recorded200.6108.4+92.2
#77 / R7Jermichael Finley TENot recorded39.797.2-57.5
#92 / R8Andrew Luck QBNot recorded134.681.8+52.9
#101 / R9Roy Helu RBNot recorded0.072.7-72.7
#116 / R10Kenny Britt WRNot recorded35.153.7-18.6
#125 / R11Green Bay Packers DEFNot recorded105.059.4+45.6
#140 / R12Coby Fleener TENot recorded0.050.6-50.6
#149 / R13David Akers KNot recorded126.053.3+72.7
#164 / R14Michael Crabtree WRNot recorded116.347.7+68.6
#173 / R15Daniel Thomas RBNot recorded0.048.2-48.2

the Skeet A

No Shoes No Shirt No Homo · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: +5.9 points · total +89.0 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Drew Brees (#8, +78.6). Worst pick: Beanie Wells (#56, -122.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#8 / R1Drew Brees QBNot recorded286.0207.4+78.6
#17 / R2Frank Gore RBNot recorded187.9195.8-7.9
#32 / R3Brandon Marshall WRNot recorded212.6155.9+56.7
#41 / R4Tony Gonzalez TENot recorded136.9128.5+8.4
#56 / R5Beanie Wells RBNot recorded0.0122.7-122.7
#65 / R6Stevan Ridley RBNot recorded180.0110.8+69.2
#80 / R7Houston Texans DEFNot recorded151.096.9+54.1
#89 / R8Percy Harvin WRNot recorded99.384.7+14.6
#104 / R9Malcom Floyd WRNot recorded111.470.2+41.2
#113 / R10Sam Bradford QBNot recorded11.557.2-45.7
#128 / R11Justin Blackmon WRNot recorded62.352.8+9.5
#137 / R12Jahvid Best RBNot recorded0.043.3-43.3
#152 / R13Jon Baldwin WRNot recorded0.054.7-54.7
#161 / R14Rob Bironas KNot recorded90.049.0+41.0
#176 / R15Dustin Keller TENot recorded35.745.8-10.1

Christian Umbach B

Long Distance Conection · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: +4.9 points · total +73.9 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Chicago Bears (#117, +143.2). Worst pick: Nate Washington (#76, -63.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#4 / R1Aaron Rodgers QBNot recorded275.8209.0+66.8
#21 / R2Marshawn Lynch RBNot recorded235.2185.8+49.4
#28 / R3Roddy White WRNot recorded172.9168.9+4.0
#45 / R4Jordy Nelson WRNot recorded103.8131.0-27.2
#52 / R5Shonn Greene RBNot recorded74.4129.8-55.4
#69 / R6Aaron Hernandez TENot recorded65.4105.9-40.5
#76 / R7Nate Washington WRNot recorded35.898.8-63.0
#93 / R8Anquan Boldin WRNot recorded97.179.9+17.2
#100 / R9C.J. Spiller RBNot recorded150.673.2+77.4
#117 / R10Chicago Bears DEFNot recorded197.053.8+143.2
#124 / R11Carson Palmer QBNot recorded103.560.1+43.5
#141 / R12LeGarrette Blount RBNot recorded0.053.1-53.1
#148 / R13Mario Manningham WRNot recorded2.052.2-50.2
#165 / R14Mark Sanchez QBNot recorded0.046.3-46.3
#172 / R15Heath Miller TENot recorded57.248.9+8.3

Jordon Nutter B

The Catalina Wine Mixer · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -4.8 points · total -72.0 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Doug Martin (#39, +107.6). Worst pick: Chris Johnson (#10, -71.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#10 / R1Chris Johnson RBNot recorded135.7207.0-71.3
#15 / R2Cam Newton QBNot recorded248.1201.0+47.1
#34 / R3A.J. Green WRNot recorded200.2147.5+52.7
#39 / R4Doug Martin RBNot recorded240.6133.0+107.6
#58 / R5BenJarvus Green-Ellis RBNot recorded75.2123.6-48.4
#63 / R6Vincent Jackson WRNot recorded180.5117.9+62.6
#82 / R7Pierre Garcon WRNot recorded63.496.4-33.0
#87 / R8Darrius Heyward-Bey WRNot recorded28.888.4-59.6
#106 / R9Josh Freeman QBNot recorded143.566.4+77.1
#111 / R10Peyton Hillis RBNot recorded0.060.0-60.0
#130 / R11Jacob Tamme TENot recorded13.450.6-37.2
#135 / R12Randy Moss WRNot recorded0.043.4-43.4
#154 / R13Steve Smith WRNot recorded0.049.4-49.4
#159 / R14Greg Olsen TENot recorded74.947.7+27.2
#178 / R15Rashad Jennings RBNot recorded0.044.3-44.3

Keetz C

Mighty Rats · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -14.2 points · total -212.6 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Reggie Wayne (#88, +58.5). Worst pick: Ryan Mathews (#9, -132.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#9 / R1Ryan Mathews RBNot recorded75.0207.6-132.6
#16 / R2Matthew Stafford QBNot recorded205.4198.9+6.5
#33 / R3Jimmy Graham TENot recorded125.9148.6-22.7
#40 / R4Victor Cruz WRNot recorded155.9130.2+25.7
#57 / R5Marques Colston WRNot recorded121.6123.5-1.9
#64 / R6Miles Austin WRNot recorded116.0114.0+2.0
#81 / R7Reggie Bush RBNot recorded146.095.1+50.9
#88 / R8Reggie Wayne WRNot recorded145.587.0+58.5
#105 / R9James Starks RBNot recorded0.068.3-68.3
#112 / R10Andy Dalton QBNot recorded43.558.4-14.9
#129 / R11Greg Little WRNot recorded19.252.2-33.0
#136 / R12Ryan Williams RBNot recorded2.642.9-40.3
#153 / R13Kevin Smith RBNot recorded28.152.4-24.3
#160 / R14Brandon LaFell WRNot recorded8.549.5-41.0
#177 / R15Mikel Leshoure RBNot recorded67.945.0+22.9

Carson Nutter C

Team Shrinkage · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -18.3 points · total -274.4 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Peyton Manning (#26, +111.4). Worst pick: Fred Jackson (#23, -113.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#2 / R1Ray Rice RBNot recorded221.6207.4+14.2
#23 / R2Fred Jackson RBNot recorded68.5182.3-113.8
#26 / R3Peyton Manning QBNot recorded286.8175.4+111.4
#47 / R4Demaryius Thomas WRNot recorded163.0135.6+27.4
#50 / R5Brandon Lloyd WRNot recorded66.0127.5-61.5
#71 / R6Tim Hightower RBNot recorded0.098.2-98.2
#74 / R7Jared Cook TENot recorded61.398.5-37.2
#95 / R8Devery Henderson WRNot recorded7.578.7-71.2
#98 / R9Ryan Fitzpatrick QBNot recorded48.075.3-27.3
#119 / R10Randall Cobb WRNot recorded124.258.1+66.1
#122 / R11Brian Hartline WRNot recorded10.862.8-52.0
#143 / R12Evan Royster RBNot recorded0.051.6-51.6
#146 / R13New York Giants DEFNot recorded132.054.9+77.1
#167 / R14Golden Tate WRNot recorded31.346.7-15.4
#170 / R15Dan Bailey KNot recorded7.049.3-42.3

Mark Garner C

Thunderbuddies · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -23.5 points · total -351.9 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 7 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Robert Griffin III (#67, +69.4). Worst pick: Maurice Jones-Drew (#6, -155.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#6 / R1Maurice Jones-Drew RBNot recorded52.5208.2-155.7
#19 / R2Eli Manning QBNot recorded81.9191.4-109.5
#30 / R3Wes Welker WRNot recorded154.9160.9-6.0
#43 / R4Antonio Gates TENot recorded64.8131.4-66.6
#54 / R5DeSean Jackson WRNot recorded73.5128.0-54.5
#67 / R6Robert Griffin III QBNot recorded178.6109.3+69.4
#78 / R7Baltimore Ravens DEFNot recorded112.099.6+12.4
#91 / R8Denarius Moore WRNot recorded58.382.0-23.7
#102 / R9Jonathan Stewart RBNot recorded40.669.0-28.4
#115 / R10Michael Bush RBNot recorded47.755.8-8.1
#126 / R11Emmanuel Sanders WRNot recorded17.054.7-37.7
#139 / R12Owen Daniels TENot recorded70.147.1+23.0
#150 / R13Sebastian Janikowski KNot recorded110.053.6+56.4
#163 / R14New York Jets DEFNot recorded19.048.1-29.1
#174 / R15Robbie Gould KNot recorded53.046.9+6.1

The Drake D

The Drake · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -24.7 points · total -370.8 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Tom Brady (#3, +114.4). Worst pick: Isaac Redman (#51, -107.4).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#3 / R1Tom Brady QBNot recorded320.9206.5+114.4
#22 / R2Rob Gronkowski TENot recorded132.8184.3-51.5
#27 / R3Michael Turner RBNot recorded109.7172.3-62.6
#46 / R4Mike Wallace WRNot recorded107.1135.5-28.4
#51 / R5Isaac Redman RBNot recorded21.5128.9-107.4
#70 / R6Torrey Smith WRNot recorded131.5101.9+29.6
#75 / R7San Francisco 49ers DEFNot recorded111.097.0+14.0
#94 / R8Jay Cutler QBNot recorded10.478.3-67.9
#99 / R9Mark Ingram RBNot recorded0.072.2-72.2
#118 / R10Sidney Rice WRNot recorded61.956.1+5.8
#123 / R11Terrell Owens WRNot recorded0.063.5-63.5
#142 / R12Chad Johnson WRNot recorded0.052.9-52.9
#147 / R13Toby Gerhart RBNot recorded0.054.1-54.1
#166 / R14Tim Tebow QBNot recorded0.046.2-46.2
#171 / R15Matt Prater KNot recorded121.048.9+72.1

Anthony Oliver D

dirtychicken · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -27.6 points · total -414.5 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 9 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Matt Ryan (#38, +133.4). Worst pick: Michael Floyd (#59, -120.1).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#11 / R1Trent Richardson RBNot recorded177.2205.1-27.9
#14 / R2Calvin Johnson WRNot recorded195.7201.2-5.5
#35 / R3Vernon Davis TENot recorded65.9144.9-79.0
#38 / R4Matt Ryan QBNot recorded274.0140.6+133.4
#59 / R5Michael Floyd WRNot recorded0.0120.1-120.1
#62 / R6Dexter McCluster WRNot recorded8.2118.6-110.4
#83 / R7Alex Smith QBNot recorded8.794.8-86.1
#86 / R8Cincinnati Bengals DEFNot recorded113.090.5+22.5
#107 / R9Fred Davis TENot recorded4.665.2-60.6
#110 / R10Alshon Jeffery WRNot recorded13.257.3-44.1
#131 / R11Jacoby Ford WRNot recorded0.046.4-46.4
#134 / R12Chris Rainey RBNot recorded0.043.3-43.3
#155 / R13DeAngelo Williams RBNot recorded36.548.9-12.4
#158 / R14Stephen Gostkowski KNot recorded153.049.6+103.4
#179 / R15Leonard Hankerson WRNot recorded5.643.5-37.9

CJ Nutter F

We'll Give it to Him · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -29.7 points · total -445.9 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 10 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Ben Roethlisberger (#84, +112.9). Worst pick: Darren McFadden (#12, -97.4).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#12 / R1Darren McFadden RBNot recorded104.6202.0-97.4
#13 / R2Jamaal Charles RBNot recorded178.4203.7-25.3
#36 / R3Steven Jackson RBNot recorded82.0142.5-60.5
#37 / R4Steve Smith WRNot recorded134.8142.0-7.2
#60 / R5Dwayne Bowe WRNot recorded72.7119.4-46.7
#61 / R6Steve Johnson WRNot recorded93.6120.4-26.8
#84 / R7Ben Roethlisberger QBNot recorded206.693.7+112.9
#85 / R8Eric Decker WRNot recorded85.491.6-6.2
#108 / R9Brandon Pettigrew TENot recorded28.461.1-32.7
#109 / R10Robert Meachem WRNot recorded3.059.6-56.6
#132 / R11Ben Tate RBNot recorded0.045.9-45.9
#133 / R12Titus Young WRNot recorded2.445.0-42.6
#156 / R13Matt Flynn QBNot recorded0.049.4-49.4
#157 / R14Shane Vereen RBNot recorded0.048.9-48.9
#180 / R15Felix Jones RBNot recorded32.444.8-12.4

Austin Hammett F

Return of the Crosby · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -34.5 points · total -516.8 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Mike Williams (#103, +14.5). Worst pick: Larry Fitzgerald (#18, -110.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#7 / R1Matt Forte RBNot recorded143.4208.2-64.8
#18 / R2Larry Fitzgerald WRNot recorded86.2197.0-110.8
#31 / R3Hakeem Nicks WRNot recorded87.2156.9-69.7
#42 / R4DeMarco Murray RBNot recorded102.8130.5-27.7
#55 / R5Philip Rivers QBNot recorded90.4126.0-35.7
#66 / R6Antonio Brown WRNot recorded70.3111.9-41.6
#79 / R7Jason Witten TENot recorded51.596.2-44.7
#90 / R8Pittsburgh Steelers DEFNot recorded94.084.2+9.8
#103 / R9Mike Williams WRNot recorded85.571.0+14.5
#114 / R10Donald Brown RBNot recorded10.155.6-45.5
#127 / R11Joe Flacco QBNot recorded41.453.6-12.2
#138 / R12Austin Collie WRNot recorded0.044.2-44.2
#151 / R13Mason Crosby KNot recorded59.053.6+5.4
#162 / R14Dallas Clark TENot recorded0.048.5-48.5
#175 / R15James Jones WRNot recorded45.346.6-1.3

Bryan Stein F

The Golden Taters · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -38.1 points · total -572.0 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Matt Bryant (#169, +98.5). Worst pick: Greg Jennings (#25, -158.4).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#1 / R1Arian Foster RBNot recorded244.2210.1+34.1
#24 / R2Michael Vick QBNot recorded139.3178.0-38.7
#25 / R3Greg Jennings WRNot recorded18.0176.4-158.4
#48 / R4Ahmad Bradshaw RBNot recorded38.5131.9-93.4
#49 / R5Darren Sproles RBNot recorded21.7130.1-108.4
#72 / R6Willis McGahee RBNot recorded62.999.2-36.3
#73 / R7Jeremy Maclin WRNot recorded86.598.6-12.1
#96 / R8Santonio Holmes WRNot recorded31.276.7-45.5
#97 / R9Matt Schaub QBNot recorded41.076.5-35.5
#120 / R10Vincent Brown WRNot recorded0.058.0-58.0
#121 / R11Isaiah Pead RBNot recorded0.060.6-60.6
#144 / R12Brian Quick WRNot recorded0.053.2-53.2
#145 / R13Kyle Rudolph TENot recorded68.352.5+15.8
#168 / R14Philadelphia Eagles DEFNot recorded26.046.3-20.3
#169 / R15Matt Bryant KNot recorded146.047.5+98.5