2014 draft board

The Funky Bunch · 180 picks · 15 rounds · 12 teams · season 2014 · all drafts · Manager report cards
Speed
Pick 0 of 180
RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.
RD
Chad
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

Christian Umbach A

The Mustard Seed Conspiracy · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -3.4 points · total -51.7 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 1 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Peyton Manning (#23, +122.0). Worst pick: Trent Richardson (#50, -99.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#2 / R1Marshawn Lynch RBNot recorded251.7207.4+44.3
#23 / R2Peyton Manning QBNot recorded304.3182.3+122.0
#26 / R3Julius Thomas TENot recorded120.9175.4-54.5
#47 / R4T.Y. Hilton WRNot recorded176.5135.6+40.9
#50 / R5Trent Richardson RBNot recorded27.7127.5-99.8
#71 / R6Anquan Boldin WRNot recorded86.498.2-11.8
#74 / R7Mike Wallace WRNot recorded145.898.5+47.3
#95 / R8Danny Amendola WRNot recorded0.078.7-78.7
#98 / R9Darren Sproles RBNot recorded102.875.3+27.5
#119 / R10LeGarrette Blount RBNot recorded0.058.1-58.1
#122 / R11Steve Johnson WRNot recorded0.062.8-62.8
#143 / R12Aaron Dobson WRNot recorded0.051.6-51.6
#146 / R13San Francisco 49ers DEFNot recorded103.054.9+48.1
#167 / R14Nick Novak KNot recorded111.046.7+64.3
#170 / R15Ryan Tannehill QBNot recorded20.649.3-28.7

The Drake A

The Drake · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -4.3 points · total -63.8 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Russell Wilson (#82, +186.6). Worst pick: Ryan Mathews (#39, -133.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#10 / R1Calvin Johnson WRNot recorded139.8207.0-67.2
#15 / R2Drew Brees QBNot recorded274.3201.0+73.3
#34 / R3Frank Gore RBNot recorded127.0147.5-20.5
#39 / R4Ryan Mathews RBNot recorded0.0133.0-133.0
#58 / R5Sammy Watkins WRNot recorded106.0123.6-17.6
#63 / R6Julian Edelman WRNot recorded130.6117.9+12.7
#82 / R7Russell Wilson QBNot recorded282.996.4+186.6
#87 / R8Riley Cooper WRNot recorded2.988.4-85.5
#106 / R9Seattle Seahawks DEFNot recorded121.066.4+54.6
#111 / R10Danny Woodhead RBNot recorded0.160.0-59.9
#130 / R11Greg Jennings WRNot recorded0.450.6-50.2
#135 / R12Justin Hunter WRNot recorded29.643.4-13.8
#154 / R13Matt Prater KNot recorded8.049.4-41.4
#159 / R14Coby Fleener TENot recorded42.047.7-5.7
#178 / R15Mark Ingram RBNot recorded147.944.3+103.6

the Skeet B

Good Luck In High School · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -8.0 points · total -120.2 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Colin Kaepernick (#91, +105.8). Worst pick: Torrey Smith (#54, -76.7).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#6 / R1Eddie Lacy RBNot recorded213.9208.2+5.7
#19 / R2Jordy Nelson WRNot recorded221.3191.4+29.9
#30 / R3Andre Ellington RBNot recorded118.0160.9-42.9
#43 / R4Michael Crabtree WRNot recorded81.1131.4-50.3
#54 / R5Torrey Smith WRNot recorded51.3128.0-76.7
#67 / R6Joique Bell RBNot recorded69.1109.3-40.2
#78 / R7DeAndre Hopkins WRNot recorded131.499.6+31.8
#91 / R8Colin Kaepernick QBNot recorded187.882.0+105.8
#102 / R9Maurice Jones-Drew RBNot recorded0.069.0-69.0
#115 / R10Khiry Robinson RBNot recorded0.055.8-55.8
#126 / R11Andy Dalton QBNot recorded49.154.7-5.6
#139 / R12Zach Ertz TENot recorded70.747.1+23.6
#150 / R13St. Louis Rams DEFNot recorded45.053.6-8.6
#163 / R14Kenny Stills WRNot recorded0.048.1-48.1
#174 / R15Dan Bailey KNot recorded127.046.9+80.1

Bryan Stein B

Corner Formerly Knownas Prince · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -8.5 points · total -126.9 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Matt Ryan (#108, +94.6). Worst pick: Robert Griffin III (#84, -81.4).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#12 / R1Demaryius Thomas WRNot recorded218.4202.0+16.4
#13 / R2Le'Veon Bell RBNot recorded277.5203.7+73.8
#36 / R3Keenan Allen WRNot recorded98.3142.5-44.2
#37 / R4Rob Gronkowski TENot recorded184.4142.0+42.4
#60 / R5Rashad Jennings RBNot recorded94.2119.4-25.2
#61 / R6Shane Vereen RBNot recorded51.3120.4-69.1
#84 / R7Robert Griffin III QBNot recorded12.493.7-81.4
#85 / R8Dwayne Bowe WRNot recorded14.891.6-76.8
#108 / R9Matt Ryan QBNot recorded155.761.1+94.6
#109 / R10Kelvin Benjamin WRNot recorded136.759.6+77.1
#132 / R11Christine Michael RBNot recorded0.045.9-45.9
#133 / R12Marqise Lee WRNot recorded6.245.0-38.8
#156 / R13Martellus Bennett TENot recorded4.549.4-44.9
#157 / R14Cincinnati Bengals DEFNot recorded89.048.9+40.1
#180 / R15Chris Rainey RBNot recorded0.044.8-44.8

Keetz C

dont call it a cUMBACH · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -8.7 points · total -130.9 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jay Cutler (#117, +156.6). Worst pick: Wes Welker (#45, -112.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#4 / R1LeSean McCoy RBNot recorded160.0209.0-49.0
#21 / R2Brandon Marshall WRNot recorded118.1185.8-67.7
#28 / R3Randall Cobb WRNot recorded183.8168.9+14.9
#45 / R4Wes Welker WRNot recorded18.7131.0-112.3
#52 / R5Ben Tate RBNot recorded44.4129.8-85.4
#69 / R6Stevan Ridley RBNot recorded8.9105.9-97.0
#76 / R7Kendall Wright WRNot recorded39.298.8-59.6
#93 / R8Ray Rice RBNot recorded0.079.9-79.9
#100 / R9Jason Witten TENot recorded54.473.2-18.8
#117 / R10Jay Cutler QBNot recorded210.453.8+156.6
#124 / R11Ben Roethlisberger QBNot recorded140.660.1+80.5
#141 / R12Odell Beckham WRNot recorded154.453.1+101.3
#148 / R13Arizona Cardinals DEFNot recorded104.052.2+51.8
#165 / R14Justin Tucker KNot recorded129.046.3+82.7
#172 / R15Andre Brown RBNot recorded0.048.9-48.9

Anthony Oliver C

Dont send me poop pictures · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -13.2 points · total -197.8 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Tony Romo (#79, +98.5). Worst pick: Reggie Bush (#18, -167.9).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#7 / R1Arian Foster RBNot recorded226.2208.2+18.0
#18 / R2Reggie Bush RBNot recorded29.1197.0-167.9
#31 / R3Vincent Jackson WRNot recorded25.4156.9-131.5
#42 / R4DeSean Jackson WRNot recorded29.1130.5-101.4
#55 / R5Jeremy Maclin WRNot recorded170.7126.0+44.7
#66 / R6Emmanuel Sanders WRNot recorded178.6111.9+66.7
#79 / R7Tony Romo QBNot recorded194.796.2+98.5
#90 / R8Darren McFadden RBNot recorded15.884.2-68.4
#103 / R9Steve Smith WRNot recorded30.871.0-40.2
#114 / R10DeAngelo Williams RBNot recorded2.855.6-52.8
#127 / R11Antonio Gates TENot recorded111.753.6+58.1
#138 / R12Doug Baldwin WRNot recorded48.644.2+4.4
#151 / R13New England Patriots DEFNot recorded75.053.6+21.4
#162 / R14Joe Flacco QBNot recorded76.648.5+28.1
#175 / R15Phil Dawson KNot recorded71.046.6+24.4

Austin Hammett C

The Gotham Rogues · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -19.0 points · total -284.4 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 7 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Matthew Stafford (#53, +101.4). Worst pick: Doug Martin (#29, -126.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#5 / R1Matt Forte RBNot recorded237.2206.2+31.0
#20 / R2Julio Jones WRNot recorded176.9188.5-11.6
#29 / R3Doug Martin RBNot recorded39.2165.5-126.3
#44 / R4Larry Fitzgerald WRNot recorded85.5131.6-46.1
#53 / R5Matthew Stafford QBNot recorded230.0128.6+101.4
#68 / R6Vernon Davis TENot recorded32.1108.4-76.3
#77 / R7Mike Evans WRNot recorded146.497.2+49.2
#92 / R8Cecil Shorts WRNot recorded15.081.8-66.8
#101 / R9Knowshon Moreno RBNot recorded0.472.7-72.3
#116 / R10Marvin Jones WRNot recorded0.053.7-53.7
#125 / R11Shonn Greene RBNot recorded0.059.4-59.4
#140 / R12Alex Smith QBNot recorded16.050.6-34.7
#149 / R13Pittsburgh Steelers DEFNot recorded85.053.3+31.7
#164 / R14Mason Crosby KNot recorded138.047.7+90.3
#173 / R15Brian Hartline WRNot recorded7.448.2-40.8

Chad D

Cworld Mafia · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -27.6 points · total -414.2 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Andrew Luck (#62, +191.5). Worst pick: Victor Cruz (#35, -111.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#11 / R1A.J. Green WRNot recorded130.1205.1-75.0
#14 / R2Giovani Bernard RBNot recorded125.8201.2-75.4
#35 / R3Victor Cruz WRNot recorded33.7144.9-111.2
#38 / R4C.J. Spiller RBNot recorded40.4140.6-100.2
#59 / R5Marques Colston WRNot recorded27.4120.1-92.7
#62 / R6Andrew Luck QBNot recorded310.1118.6+191.5
#83 / R7Jordan Cameron TENot recorded26.094.8-68.8
#86 / R8Tom Brady QBNot recorded110.990.5+20.4
#107 / R9Markus Wheaton WRNot recorded21.965.2-43.3
#110 / R10Bernard Pierce RBNot recorded0.057.3-57.3
#131 / R11Robert Woods WRNot recorded5.246.4-41.2
#134 / R12Tre Mason RBNot recorded90.643.3+47.3
#155 / R13Carolina Panthers DEFNot recorded47.048.9-1.9
#158 / R14Blair Walsh KNot recorded46.049.6-3.6
#179 / R15Heath Miller TENot recorded40.743.5-2.8

Jordon Nutter D

Chicken of the Cave · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -30.1 points · total -450.8 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 9 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Aaron Rodgers (#32, +173.8). Worst pick: Montee Ball (#8, -180.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#8 / R1Montee Ball RBNot recorded27.4207.4-180.0
#17 / R2Dez Bryant WRNot recorded206.1195.8+10.3
#32 / R3Aaron Rodgers QBNot recorded329.7155.9+173.8
#41 / R4Pierre Garcon WRNot recorded81.8128.5-46.7
#56 / R5Bishop Sankey RBNot recorded46.3122.7-76.4
#65 / R6Chris Johnson RBNot recorded27.7110.8-83.1
#80 / R7Terrance Williams WRNot recorded24.196.9-72.8
#89 / R8Greg Olsen TENot recorded87.684.7+2.9
#104 / R9Tavon Austin WRNot recorded0.070.2-70.2
#113 / R10Pierre Thomas RBNot recorded2.357.2-54.9
#128 / R11Dennis Pitta TENot recorded12.552.8-40.3
#137 / R12Josh Gordon WRNot recorded30.343.3-13.0
#152 / R13Stephen Gostkowski KNot recorded149.054.7+94.3
#161 / R14Devonta Freeman RBNot recorded0.049.0-49.0
#176 / R15Teddy Bridgewater QBNot recorded0.045.8-45.8

Carson Nutter F

The Van Buren Boys · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -31.3 points · total -468.9 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 10 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Steven Hauschka (#166, +74.8). Worst pick: Zac Stacy (#22, -146.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#3 / R1Jamaal Charles RBNot recorded204.2206.5-2.3
#22 / R2Zac Stacy RBNot recorded37.5184.3-146.8
#27 / R3Alshon Jeffery WRNot recorded168.5172.3-3.8
#46 / R4Roddy White WRNot recorded100.2135.5-35.3
#51 / R5Cordarrelle Patterson WRNot recorded38.7128.9-90.2
#70 / R6Nick Foles QBNot recorded119.3101.9+17.4
#75 / R7Eric Decker WRNot recorded35.097.0-62.0
#94 / R8Brandin Cooks WRNot recorded48.778.3-29.6
#99 / R9Steven Jackson RBNot recorded13.472.2-58.8
#118 / R10Stepfan Taylor RBNot recorded0.056.1-56.1
#123 / R11Jordan Reed TENot recorded22.963.5-40.6
#142 / R12Johnny Manziel QBNot recorded2.152.9-50.8
#147 / R13Kansas City Chiefs DEFNot recorded65.054.1+10.9
#166 / R14Steven Hauschka KNot recorded121.046.2+74.8
#171 / R15Ahmad Bradshaw RBNot recorded53.348.9+4.4

Nick Moretti F

Fresh Prince of DubTown · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -31.6 points · total -473.8 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Philip Rivers (#96, +126.4). Worst pick: Adrian Peterson (#1, -200.8).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#1 / R1Adrian Peterson RBNot recorded9.3210.1-200.8
#24 / R2Antonio Brown WRNot recorded233.1178.0+55.1
#25 / R3Alfred Morris RBNot recorded164.7176.4-11.7
#48 / R4Percy Harvin WRNot recorded78.6131.9-53.3
#49 / R5Michael Floyd WRNot recorded69.6130.1-60.5
#72 / R6Reggie Wayne WRNot recorded28.099.2-71.2
#73 / R7Fred Jackson RBNot recorded5.198.6-93.5
#96 / R8Philip Rivers QBNot recorded203.176.7+126.4
#97 / R9Hakeem Nicks WRNot recorded3.076.5-73.5
#120 / R10Kyle Rudolph TENot recorded30.158.0-27.9
#121 / R11Chris Ivory RBNot recorded88.260.6+27.6
#144 / R12Denver Broncos DEFNot recorded98.053.2+44.8
#145 / R13Josh McCown QBNot recorded0.052.5-52.5
#168 / R14Shayne Graham KNot recorded11.046.3-35.3
#169 / R15Dexter McCluster RBNot recorded0.047.5-47.5

CJ Nutter F

Patio Date Rape · 15 picks · 15 graded

Average vs slot: -35.1 points · total -527.2 ÷ 15 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: DeMarco Murray (#16, +77.1). Worst pick: Toby Gerhart (#33, -141.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#9 / R1Jimmy Graham TENot recorded139.5207.6-68.1
#16 / R2DeMarco Murray RBNot recorded276.0198.9+77.1
#33 / R3Toby Gerhart RBNot recorded7.4148.6-141.2
#40 / R4Andre Johnson WRNot recorded64.1130.2-66.1
#57 / R5Lamar Miller RBNot recorded31.0123.5-92.5
#64 / R6Golden Tate WRNot recorded155.6114.0+41.6
#81 / R7Cam Newton QBNot recorded44.495.1-50.7
#88 / R8Rueben Randle WRNot recorded18.187.0-68.9
#105 / R9James Jones WRNot recorded19.868.3-48.5
#112 / R10Terrance West RBNot recorded40.358.4-18.1
#129 / R11Jeremy Hill RBNot recorded103.952.2+51.7
#136 / R12Jordan Matthews WRNot recorded43.642.9+0.7
#153 / R13Carlos Hyde RBNot recorded2.752.4-49.7
#160 / R14Jarrett Boykin WRNot recorded0.049.5-49.5
#177 / R15Lance Dunbar RBNot recorded0.045.0-45.0