2024 rookie draft board

D3 Dynasty League · 60 picks · 5 rounds · 12 teams · season 2024 · all drafts · Manager report cards

Speed

Pick 0 of 60

RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.

RD	Josh Bayer	Jordon Nutter	Tommarello	Keetz	Jared Nutter	Eric Harper	Talon Cain	Charles Hartz	the Skeet	Bryan Stein	CJ Nutter	Carson Nutter
1	#1 CalebCHI QB Williams #9 BrianJAX WR Thomas	#2 MarvinARI WR Harrison	#3 MalikNYG WR Nabers #10 J.J.MIN QB McCarthy	#4 JaydenWAS QB Daniels #8 XavierKC WR Worthy	#5 DrakeNE QB Maye	#6 RomeCHI WR Odunze	#7 BrockLV TE Bowers #12 LaddLAC WR McConkey	#11 KeonBUF WR Coleman	No selection	No selection	No selection	No selection
2	#13 JonathonCAR RB Brooks #17 XavierCAR WR Legette	#14 BoDEN QB Nix	#23 BenWAS TE Sinnott	#20 BlakeLAR RB Corum	#15 RickySF WR Pearsall #22 Ja'LynnNE WR Polk	#18 MichaelATL QB Penix	#19 AdonaiIND WR Mitchell	No selection	#16 TreyARI RB Benson	#21 RomanPIT WR Wilson	#24 MalachiNYJ WR Corley	No selection
3	#25 MarShawnGB RB Lloyd	#26 TroyDEN WR Franklin #30 TyroneNYG RB Tracy	#29 KimaniLAC RB Vidal	#31 LukeWAS WR McCaffrey	No selection	No selection	#35 BuckyTB RB Irving	No selection	#28 JaylenMIA RB Wright	#33 JavonNE WR Baker	#27 JermaineCIN WR Burton #34 Ja'TavionCAR TE Sanders #36 RayBUF RB Davis	#32 SpencerNO QB Rattler
4	#39 MalikMIA WR Washington	#38 AudricDEN RB Estime	#43 IsaacSF RB Guerendo	#40 JalenTB WR McMillan	#41 WillPHI RB Shipley #46 DevontezBAL WR Walker	#42 ColbyLAR TE Parkinson	#48 FrankBUF RB Gore	#47 CadeHOU TE Stover	No selection	#45 BraelonNYJ RB Allen	#37 DylanLV RB Laube	#44 BrendenLAC WR Rice
5	#49 TheoNYG TE Johnson #58 JohnnyPHI WR Wilson	#50 JordanNYJ QB Travis	#51 RasheenBAL RB Ali	#56 BubNO WR Means	#53 JaredKC TE Wiley	No selection	#60 JoeNE QB Milton	#59 Tom QB Brady	#52 ErickCIN TE All	#54 AiniasPHI WR Smith #57 KendallPHI RB Milton	No selection	#55 JacobSF WR Cowing

Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

Keetz A

keetz39 · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +56.3 points · total +338.0 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 1 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jayden Daniels (#4, +247.6). Worst pick: Blake Corum (#20, -29.8).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#4 / R1	Jayden Daniels QB	the Skeet · traded pick	355.8	108.3	+247.6
#8 / R1	Xavier Worthy WR	Keetz	187.2	86.1	+101.1
#20 / R2	Blake Corum RB	Keetz	0.0	29.8	-29.8
#31 / R3	Luke McCaffrey WR	Carson Nutter · traded pick	0.0	13.4	-13.4
#40 / R4	Jalen McMillan WR	the Skeet · traded pick	53.3	12.0	+41.3
#56 / R5	Bub Means WR	Keetz	0.0	8.7	-8.7

Talon Cain A

Pay Backs A-B*tch · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +55.5 points · total +332.7 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Ladd McConkey (#12, +162.5). Worst pick: Adonai Mitchell (#19, -32.3).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#7 / R1	Brock Bowers TE	Carson Nutter · traded pick	219.6	96.8	+122.8
#12 / R1	Ladd McConkey WR	Talon Cain	226.0	63.5	+162.5
#19 / R2	Adonai Mitchell WR	Carson Nutter · traded pick	0.0	32.3	-32.3
#35 / R3	Bucky Irving RB	Charles Hartz · traded pick	106.8	13.2	+93.6
#48 / R4	Frank Gore RB	Talon Cain	0.0	6.8	-6.8
#60 / R5	Joe Milton QB	Talon Cain	0.0	7.2	-7.2

Jordon Nutter B

West Arlen Propane · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +51.0 points · total +306.0 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Tyrone Tracy (#30, +149.4). Worst pick: Troy Franklin (#26, -13.5).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#2 / R1	Marvin Harrison WR	Jordon Nutter	191.4	116.9	+74.5
#14 / R2	Bo Nix QB	Jordon Nutter	158.7	52.1	+106.7
#26 / R3	Troy Franklin WR	Jordon Nutter	2.9	16.4	-13.5
#30 / R3	Tyrone Tracy RB	Eric Harper · traded pick	162.3	12.9	+149.4
#38 / R4	Audric Estime RB	Jordon Nutter	7.0	12.2	-5.2
#50 / R5	Jordan Travis QB	Jordon Nutter	0.0	5.8	-5.8

Josh Bayer B

Very Good Construction Co · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: +30.8 points · total +246.1 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Brian Thomas (#9, +204.0). Worst pick: Jonathon Brooks (#13, -50.9).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#1 / R1	Caleb Williams QB	Josh Bayer	254.5	120.6	+134.0
#9 / R1	Brian Thomas WR	Bryan Stein · traded pick	284.0	80.0	+204.0
#13 / R2	Jonathon Brooks RB	Josh Bayer	7.5	58.4	-50.9
#17 / R2	Xavier Legette WR	Jared Nutter · traded pick	43.6	40.1	+3.5
#25 / R3	MarShawn Lloyd RB	Josh Bayer	0.0	17.4	-17.4
#39 / R4	Malik Washington WR	Tommarello · traded pick	0.0	12.2	-12.2
#49 / R5	Theo Johnson TE	Josh Bayer	0.0	6.1	-6.1
#58 / R5	Johnny Wilson WR	CJ Nutter · traded pick	0.0	8.7	-8.7

Tommarello C

The Rebuild · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +14.6 points · total +87.6 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Malik Nabers (#3, +161.3). Worst pick: J.J. McCarthy (#10, -73.9).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#3 / R1	Malik Nabers WR	Tommarello	273.6	112.3	+161.3
#10 / R1	J.J. McCarthy QB	CJ Nutter · traded pick	0.0	73.9	-73.9
#23 / R2	Ben Sinnott TE	Charles Hartz · traded pick	0.0	23.1	-23.1
#29 / R3	Kimani Vidal RB	Jared Nutter · traded pick	0.0	14.3	-14.3
#43 / R4	Isaac Guerendo RB	Carson Nutter · traded pick	52.7	9.3	+43.4
#51 / R5	Rasheen Ali RB	Tommarello	0.0	5.8	-5.8

Charles Hartz C

Booze Hounds · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: +4.0 points · total +12.0 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Keon Coleman (#11, +26.2). Worst pick: Cade Stover (#47, -7.6).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#11 / R1	Keon Coleman WR	Charles Hartz	95.0	68.8	+26.2
#47 / R4	Cade Stover TE	Charles Hartz	0.0	7.6	-7.6
#59 / R5	Tom Brady QB	Charles Hartz	0.0	6.6	-6.6

Bryan Stein C

Dilly's Destroyers · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -5.4 points · total -26.9 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 7 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Braelon Allen (#45, +32.2). Worst pick: Roman Wilson (#21, -28.6).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#21 / R2	Roman Wilson WR	Bryan Stein	0.0	28.6	-28.6
#33 / R3	Javon Baker WR	Bryan Stein	0.0	13.6	-13.6
#45 / R4	Braelon Allen RB	Bryan Stein	40.4	8.2	+32.2
#54 / R5	Ainias Smith WR	Eric Harper · traded pick	0.0	7.7	-7.7
#57 / R5	Kendall Milton RB	Bryan Stein	0.0	9.2	-9.2

Eric Harper D

2 Girls 1 Kupp · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: -6.2 points · total -18.7 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Colby Parkinson (#42, +33.9). Worst pick: Michael Penix (#18, -36.5).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#6 / R1	Rome Odunze WR	Eric Harper	85.0	101.2	-16.2
#18 / R2	Michael Penix QB	Eric Harper	0.0	36.5	-36.5
#42 / R4	Colby Parkinson TE	Eric Harper	44.4	10.5	+33.9

Jared Nutter D

Jnut · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: -8.2 points · total -49.2 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 9 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Drake Maye (#5, +51.0). Worst pick: Ricky Pearsall (#15, -47.5).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#5 / R1	Drake Maye QB	Jared Nutter	155.5	104.5	+51.0
#15 / R2	Ricky Pearsall WR	Tommarello · traded pick	0.0	47.5	-47.5
#22 / R2	Ja'Lynn Polk WR	CJ Nutter · traded pick	1.4	26.9	-25.5
#41 / R4	Will Shipley RB	Jared Nutter	0.0	11.5	-11.5
#46 / R4	Devontez Walker WR	CJ Nutter · traded pick	0.0	8.7	-8.7
#53 / R5	Jared Wiley TE	Jared Nutter	0.0	7.0	-7.0

Carson Nutter F

Rest In Piss Queen Lizzy · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: -9.6 points · total -28.9 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 10 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Brenden Rice (#44, -7.6). Worst pick: Spencer Rattler (#32, -13.0).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#32 / R3	Spencer Rattler QB	Keetz · traded pick	13.0	-13.0
#44 / R4	Brenden Rice WR	Keetz · traded pick	7.6	-7.6
#55 / R5	Jacob Cowing WR	Carson Nutter	8.3	-8.3

CJ Nutter F

Ripley's Reapers · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -11.2 points · total -55.8 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Ray Davis (#36, +5.0). Worst pick: Malachi Corley (#24, -19.6).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#24 / R2	Malachi Corley WR	Talon Cain · traded pick	0.0	19.6	-19.6
#27 / R3	Jermaine Burton WR	Tommarello · traded pick	0.0	15.8	-15.8
#34 / R3	Ja'Tavion Sanders TE	CJ Nutter	0.0	12.7	-12.7
#36 / R3	Ray Davis RB	Talon Cain · traded pick	18.2	13.2	+5.0
#37 / R4	Dylan Laube RB	Josh Bayer · traded pick	0.0	12.7	-12.7

the Skeet F

johndennis · 3 picks · 3 graded

Average vs slot: -16.7 points · total -50.1 ÷ 3 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Erick All (#52, -1.3). Worst pick: Trey Benson (#16, -36.8).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#16 / R2	Trey Benson RB	the Skeet	6.1	42.9	-36.8
#28 / R3	Jaylen Wright RB	the Skeet	2.4	14.4	-12.0
#52 / R5	Erick All TE	the Skeet	6.0	7.3	-1.3