2023 rookie draft board

The ShaDynasty League · 60 picks · 5 rounds · 12 teams · season 2023 · all drafts · Manager report cards

Speed

Pick 0 of 60

RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.

RD	Lorenz	Jared Nutter	Carson Nutter	Keetz	Jordon Nutter	Derek Glover	Bryan Stein	Talon Cain	Josh Bayer	Nick Moretti	CJ Nutter	the Skeet
1	#1 Bijan RB Robinson	#2 Jaxon WR Smith-Njigba #7 Zach RB Charbonnet #8 Josh WR Downs	#3 Jahmyr RB Gibbs	#4 Zay WR Flowers #10 Jalin WR Hyatt	#5 Jordan WR Addison #12 Michael TE Mayer	#6 Quentin WR Johnston	#9 Tank RB Bigsby	#11 C.J. QB Stroud	No selection	No selection	No selection	No selection
2	#13 Bryce QB Young	#19 Israel RB Abanikanda	#17 Anthony QB Richardson	No selection	No selection	#18 Zach RB Evans	#14 Devon RB Achane	No selection	#15 Tyjae RB Spears #20 Roschon RB Johnson #23 Cedric WR Tillman	#16 Dalton TE Kincaid #21 Marvin WR Mims #22 Will QB Levis	#24 Kendre RB Miller	No selection
3	#25 Darnell TE Washington	No selection	#29 Luke TE Musgrave #34 Sam TE LaPorta	#28 Kayshon WR Boutte	#27 Rashee WR Rice #32 Chase RB Brown	#30 Jonathan WR Mingo	#31 Evan RB Hull	#35 DeWayne RB McBride	#26 Sean RB Tucker #33 Deuce RB Vaughn	No selection	#36 Tyler WR Scott	No selection
4	#37 Eric RB Gray	No selection	#41 Parker WR Washington	#40 Xavier WR Hutchinson	#39 Kenny RB McIntosh	#42 Trey WR Palmer	#38 A.T. WR Perry	#48 Mohamed RB Ibrahim	#45 Hendon QB Hooker #47 Charlie WR Jones	#46 Chris RB Rodriguez	#43 Jayden WR Reed	#44 Keaton RB Mitchell
5	#49 Nathaniel WR Dell	#50 Bryce WR Ford-Wheaton	#53 Dontayvion WR Wicks #58 Jacob WR Copeland	#52 Rakim WR Jarrett	#51 Stetson QB Bennett	#54 Andrei WR Iosivas	#57 Elijah WR Higgins	#59 Max QB Duggan	#55 Michael WR Wilson	No selection	#60 Josh TE Whyle	#56 Tucker TE Kraft

Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

Carson Nutter A

cnutt · 7 picks · 7 graded

Average vs slot: +42.8 points · total +299.6 ÷ 7 graded picks · rank 1 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Sam LaPorta (#34, +184.0). Worst pick: Luke Musgrave (#29, -14.3).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#3 / R1	Jahmyr Gibbs RB	Jordon Nutter · traded pick	242.1	112.3	+129.8
#17 / R2	Anthony Richardson QB	Carson Nutter	51.8	40.1	+11.6
#29 / R3	Luke Musgrave TE	Carson Nutter	0.0	14.3	-14.3
#34 / R3	Sam LaPorta TE	Nick Moretti · traded pick	196.7	12.7	+184.0
#41 / R4	Parker Washington WR	Carson Nutter	0.0	11.5	-11.5
#53 / R5	Dontayvion Wicks WR	Carson Nutter	15.7	7.0	+8.7
#58 / R5	Jacob Copeland WR	Nick Moretti · traded pick	0.0	8.7	-8.7

Lorenz A

lorenzz14 · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: +38.9 points · total +194.3 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Bijan Robinson (#1, +125.7). Worst pick: Darnell Washington (#25, -17.4).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#1 / R1	Bijan Robinson RB	Lorenz	246.3	120.6	+125.7
#13 / R2	Bryce Young QB	Lorenz	117.1	58.4	+58.7
#25 / R3	Darnell Washington TE	Lorenz	0.0	17.4	-17.4
#37 / R4	Eric Gray RB	Lorenz	0.0	12.7	-12.7
#49 / R5	Nathaniel Dell WR	Lorenz	46.1	6.1	+40.0

Jordon Nutter B

The Blueberry Bulldogs · 6 picks · 6 graded

Average vs slot: +21.7 points · total +130.2 ÷ 6 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Rashee Rice (#27, +122.5). Worst pick: Michael Mayer (#12, -47.9).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#5 / R1	Jordan Addison WR	Carson Nutter · traded pick	189.0	104.5	+84.5
#12 / R1	Michael Mayer TE	CJ Nutter · traded pick	15.6	63.5	-47.9
#27 / R3	Rashee Rice WR	Jordon Nutter	138.3	15.8	+122.5
#32 / R3	Chase Brown RB	the Skeet · traded pick	2.2	13.0	-10.8
#39 / R4	Kenny McIntosh RB	Jordon Nutter	0.0	12.2	-12.2
#51 / R5	Stetson Bennett QB	Jordon Nutter	0.0	5.8	-5.8

Nick Moretti B

NickMoretti · 4 picks · 4 graded

Average vs slot: +10.8 points · total +43.2 ÷ 4 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Dalton Kincaid (#16, +107.4). Worst pick: Marvin Mims (#21, -28.6).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#16 / R2	Dalton Kincaid TE	Keetz · traded pick	150.3	42.9	+107.4
#21 / R2	Marvin Mims WR	Bryan Stein · traded pick	0.0	28.6	-28.6
#22 / R2	Will Levis QB	Nick Moretti	0.0	26.9	-26.9
#46 / R4	Chris Rodriguez RB	Nick Moretti	0.0	8.7	-8.7

the Skeet C

johndennis · 2 picks · 2 graded

Average vs slot: +6.3 points · total +12.6 ÷ 2 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Keaton Mitchell (#44, +21.3). Worst pick: Tucker Kraft (#56, -8.7).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#44 / R4	Keaton Mitchell RB	the Skeet	28.9	7.6	+21.3
#56 / R5	Tucker Kraft TE	the Skeet	0.0	8.7	-8.7

CJ Nutter C

Paisley's Punishers · 4 picks · 4 graded

Average vs slot: +3.9 points · total +15.5 ÷ 4 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jayden Reed (#43, +55.5). Worst pick: Kendre Miller (#24, -19.6).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#24 / R2	Kendre Miller RB	CJ Nutter	0.0	19.6	-19.6
#36 / R3	Tyler Scott WR	CJ Nutter	0.0	13.2	-13.2
#43 / R4	Jayden Reed WR	Josh Bayer · traded pick	64.8	9.3	+55.5
#60 / R5	Josh Whyle TE	CJ Nutter	0.0	7.2	-7.2

Keetz C

keetz39 · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -1.9 points · total -9.5 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 7 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Zay Flowers (#4, +98.1). Worst pick: Jalin Hyatt (#10, -73.9).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#4 / R1	Zay Flowers WR	Keetz	206.4	108.3	+98.1
#10 / R1	Jalin Hyatt WR	Nick Moretti · traded pick	0.0	73.9	-73.9
#28 / R3	Kayshon Boutte WR	Keetz	0.0	14.4	-14.4
#40 / R4	Xavier Hutchinson WR	Keetz	0.0	12.0	-12.0
#52 / R5	Rakim Jarrett WR	Keetz	0.0	7.3	-7.3

Bryan Stein D

The Peoples Jones Court · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -3.5 points · total -17.6 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Devon Achane (#14, +85.4). Worst pick: Tank Bigsby (#9, -68.3).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#9 / R1	Tank Bigsby RB	Bryan Stein	11.7	80.0	-68.3
#14 / R2	Devon Achane RB	Jared Nutter · traded pick	137.5	52.1	+85.4
#31 / R3	Evan Hull RB	Josh Bayer · traded pick	0.0	13.4	-13.4
#38 / R4	A.T. Perry WR	Jared Nutter · traded pick	0.0	12.2	-12.2
#57 / R5	Elijah Higgins WR	Bryan Stein	0.0	9.2	-9.2

Talon Cain D

Backfields and McCoys · 4 picks · 4 graded

Average vs slot: -7.5 points · total -30.1 ÷ 4 graded picks · rank 9 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: C.J. Stroud (#11, -3.6). Worst pick: DeWayne McBride (#35, -13.2).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#11 / R1	C.J. Stroud QB	Talon Cain	65.2	68.8	-3.6
#35 / R3	DeWayne McBride RB	Talon Cain	0.0	13.2	-13.2
#48 / R4	Mohamed Ibrahim RB	CJ Nutter · traded pick	0.0	6.8	-6.8
#59 / R5	Max Duggan QB	Talon Cain	0.0	6.6	-6.6

Josh Bayer F

Kyler’s Warzone Squad · 8 picks · 8 graded

Average vs slot: -19.3 points · total -154.4 ÷ 8 graded picks · rank 10 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Charlie Jones (#47, -7.6). Worst pick: Tyjae Spears (#15, -47.5).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#15 / R2	Tyjae Spears RB	Jordon Nutter · traded pick	47.5	-47.5
#20 / R2	Roschon Johnson RB	the Skeet · traded pick	29.8	-29.8
#23 / R2	Cedric Tillman WR	Talon Cain · traded pick	23.1	-23.1
#26 / R3	Sean Tucker RB	Jared Nutter · traded pick	16.4	-16.4
#33 / R3	Deuce Vaughn RB	Bryan Stein · traded pick	13.6	-13.6
#45 / R4	Hendon Hooker QB	Bryan Stein · traded pick	8.2	-8.2
#47 / R4	Charlie Jones WR	Talon Cain · traded pick	7.6	-7.6
#55 / R5	Michael Wilson WR	Josh Bayer	8.3	-8.3

Jared Nutter F

Endless Sadness · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -29.7 points · total -148.6 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Josh Downs (#8, +22.5). Worst pick: Jaxon Smith-Njigba (#2, -88.3).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Year-one points	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#2 / R1	Jaxon Smith-Njigba WR	Jared Nutter	28.6	116.9	-88.3
#7 / R1	Zach Charbonnet RB	Josh Bayer · traded pick	52.1	96.8	-44.7
#8 / R1	Josh Downs WR	the Skeet · traded pick	108.6	86.1	+22.5
#19 / R2	Israel Abanikanda RB	Josh Bayer · traded pick	0.0	32.3	-32.3
#50 / R5	Bryce Ford-Wheaton WR	Jared Nutter	0.0	5.8	-5.8

Derek Glover F

Chawwitdaba · 5 picks · 5 graded

Average vs slot: -33.8 points · total -168.8 ÷ 5 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Andrei Iosivas (#54, -7.7). Worst pick: Quentin Johnston (#6, -101.2).

Overall / round	Player	Original owner	Slot baseline	vs slot / status
#6 / R1	Quentin Johnston WR	Derek Glover	101.2	-101.2
#18 / R2	Zach Evans RB	Derek Glover	36.5	-36.5
#30 / R3	Jonathan Mingo WR	Derek Glover	12.9	-12.9
#42 / R4	Trey Palmer WR	Derek Glover	10.5	-10.5
#54 / R5	Andrei Iosivas WR	Derek Glover	7.7	-7.7