2024 startup draft board

PADL (Pitt Area Dynasty League) · 360 picks · 30 rounds · 12 teams · season 2024 · all drafts · Manager report cards
Speed
Pick 0 of 360
RB WR TE QB K / DEF “Mark value” outlines picks that beat their slot by 60+ points, or missed by 60+.
RD
Zer
mharsch75
NOB42
codyis
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Columns show selecting teams in first-selection order. Multiple picks in one round stay together; replay follows overall pick order. Original ownership, where recorded, appears separately in the report cards.

Complete manager report cards

Every selection is listed below, without replay or hover. Year-one points minus the average for nearby overall picks (±6 slots) in completed seasons gives “vs slot.” Baselines pool in-scope leagues separately for redraft, startup, and rookie drafts. A letter grade requires at least five graded teams. Team grades rank average points above or below slot within this draft: A/B/C/D/F in 20% bands; tied averages share the best rank in their tie. Imports and incomplete scoring seasons receive no grade.

Derek Glover A

Derek Henry · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +24.9 points · total +746.5 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 1 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Derrick Henry (#76, +212.7). Worst pick: Christian McCaffrey (#21, -147.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#4 / R1Ja'Marr Chase WRDerek Glover403.0258.0+145.0
#21 / R2Christian McCaffrey RBDerek Glover47.8194.8-147.0
#28 / R3Brock Purdy QBDerek Glover276.7149.4+127.3
#45 / R4Nico Collins WRDerek Glover210.6151.0+59.6
#52 / R5Bryce Young QBDerek Glover131.6140.0-8.4
#69 / R6D'Andre Swift RBDerek Glover136.496.5+39.9
#76 / R7Derrick Henry RBDerek Glover336.4123.7+212.7
#93 / R8David Montgomery RBDerek Glover221.7101.6+120.1
#100 / R9Jaylen Warren RBDerek Glover25.068.6-43.6
#117 / R10Jake Ferguson TEDerek Glover96.182.0+14.1
#124 / R11Courtland Sutton WRDerek Glover139.278.3+60.9
#141 / R12Zack Moss RBDerek Glover67.858.6+9.2
#148 / R13Jakobi Meyers WRDerek Glover140.232.9+107.3
#165 / R14Gardner Minshew QBDerek Glover56.345.9+10.5
#172 / R15Michael Mayer TEDerek Glover0.046.1-46.1
#189 / R16LeSean McCoy RBDerek Glover0.036.4-36.4
#196 / R17Rico Dowdle RBDerek Glover79.713.9+65.8
#213 / R18Jaleel McLaughlin RBDerek Glover0.029.4-29.4
#220 / R19Odell Beckham WRDerek Glover0.037.5-37.5
#237 / R20Buffalo Bills DEFDerek Glover70.021.4+48.6
#244 / R21Darren Waller TEDerek Glover0.020.2-20.2
#261 / R22Kadarius Toney WRDerek Glover0.012.8-12.8
#268 / R23Younghoe Koo KDerek Glover84.013.9+70.1
#285 / R24Daniel Bellinger TEDerek Glover0.05.8-5.8
#292 / R25Josh Reynolds WRDerek Glover0.010.1-10.1
#309 / R26Tyler Higbee TEDerek Glover0.015.3-15.3
#316 / R27Andy Dalton QBDerek Glover40.418.0+22.4
#333 / R28Mason Rudolph QBDerek Glover40.03.5+36.5
#340 / R29Trey Sermon RBDerek Glover27.15.0+22.1
#357 / R30Rashaad Penny RBDerek Glover0.013.0-13.0

Zer A

Hogan’s Heroes · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +21.6 points · total +649.4 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 2 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: James Conner (#123, +181.6). Worst pick: Dak Prescott (#27, -63.4).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#3 / R1Jalen Hurts QBZer320.1255.0+65.2
#22 / R2Jonathan Taylor RBZer244.7191.2+53.5
#27 / R3Dak Prescott QBZer85.1148.6-63.4
#46 / R4DK Metcalf WRZer191.2156.2+35.0
#51 / R5Dalton Kincaid TEZer91.5141.2-49.7
#70 / R6Davante Adams WRZer241.397.7+143.6
#75 / R7Cooper Kupp WRZer175.0113.9+61.1
#94 / R8Matthew Stafford QBZer197.299.5+97.7
#99 / R9Aaron Jones RBZer222.778.5+144.2
#118 / R10Keenan Allen WRZer75.980.9-5.0
#123 / R11James Conner RBZer253.872.2+181.6
#142 / R12Isaiah Likely TEZer14.263.1-48.9
#147 / R13Tyler Lockett WRZer63.035.5+27.5
#166 / R14Justin Tucker KZer85.042.3+42.7
#171 / R15Ezekiel Elliott RBZer0.045.5-45.5
#190 / R16Elijah Moore WRZer0.036.3-36.3
#195 / R17Cade Otton TEZer82.120.2+61.9
#214 / R18San Francisco 49ers DEFZer45.032.1+12.9
#219 / R19Pittsburgh Steelers DEFZer76.034.7+41.3
#238 / R20Greg Dortch WRZer0.023.1-23.1
#243 / R21Clyde Edwards-Helaire RBZer0.021.4-21.4
#262 / R22Tyquan Thornton WRZer0.014.3-14.3
#267 / R23Andrei Iosivas WRZer8.813.9-5.1
#286 / R24Justice Hill RBZer0.05.8-5.8
#291 / R25Jameis Winston QBZer0.09.7-9.7
#310 / R26Ka'imi Fairbairn KZer52.016.0+36.0
#315 / R27Van Jefferson WRZer0.015.0-15.0
#334 / R28DeWayne McBride RBZer0.04.6-4.6
#339 / R29Joshua Dobbs QBZer0.05.9-5.9
#358 / R30Brenton Strange TEZer12.213.6-1.4

mharsch75 B

The Shitbag Express · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +18.9 points · total +567.6 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 3 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Baker Mayfield (#77, +257.1). Worst pick: Blake Bortles (#44, -161.4).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#5 / R1Lamar Jackson QBmharsch75434.4252.9+181.5
#20 / R2A.J. Brown WRmharsch75216.9205.5+11.4
#29 / R3Chris Olave WRmharsch7558.0133.3-75.3
#44 / R4Blake Bortles QBmharsch750.0161.4-161.4
#53 / R5Rachaad White RBmharsch75168.1141.3+26.8
#68 / R6Deebo Samuel WRmharsch75153.6105.0+48.6
#77 / R7Baker Mayfield QBmharsch75381.8124.7+257.1
#92 / R8George Kittle TEmharsch75236.6106.0+130.6
#101 / R9Tony Pollard RBmharsch75200.768.0+132.7
#116 / R10AJ McCarron QBmharsch750.076.4-76.4
#125 / R11DeAndre Hopkins WRmharsch75113.279.0+34.2
#140 / R12Chase Brown RBmharsch75212.054.3+157.7
#149 / R13Bryce Perkins QBmharsch750.032.4-32.4
#164 / R14Rashid Shaheed WRmharsch7563.547.6+15.9
#173 / R15Treylon Burks WRmharsch750.041.8-41.8
#188 / R16Antonio Gibson RBmharsch750.033.7-33.7
#197 / R17Tank Bigsby RBmharsch7526.414.7+11.7
#212 / R18Hunter Henry TEmharsch7524.927.4-2.5
#221 / R19New York Jets DEFmharsch7591.035.5+55.5
#236 / R20Harrison Butker Kmharsch7579.022.5+56.5
#245 / R21Bryce Love RBmharsch750.020.1-20.1
#260 / R22K.J. Osborn WRmharsch750.015.5-15.5
#269 / R23A.J. Green WRmharsch750.014.7-14.7
#284 / R24Luke Schoonmaker TEmharsch750.07.4-7.4
#293 / R25Dazz Newsome WRmharsch750.015.4-15.4
#308 / R26Golden Tate WRmharsch750.015.6-15.6
#317 / R27Jalen Hurd WRmharsch750.015.2-15.2
#332 / R28Ricky Seals-Jones TEmharsch750.03.5-3.5
#341 / R29Kyle Rudolph TEmharsch750.07.9-7.9
#356 / R30Thaddeus Moss TEmharsch750.013.8-13.8

CJ Nutter B

Homicidal Hobbits · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +11.0 points · total +328.9 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 4 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Calvin Ridley (#111, +131.1). Worst pick: Marquise Brown (#106, -67.1).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#10 / R1Patrick Mahomes QBCJ Nutter294.0246.4+47.6
#15 / R2Breece Hall RBCJ Nutter240.9228.4+12.5
#34 / R3Tua Tagovailoa QBCJ Nutter188.6143.6+45.0
#39 / R4DeVonta Smith WRCJ Nutter199.4145.1+54.3
#58 / R5DJ Moore WRCJ Nutter232.7150.8+81.9
#63 / R6Jordan Addison WRCJ Nutter196.4139.0+57.4
#82 / R7Jaxon Smith-Njigba WRCJ Nutter231.2128.6+102.6
#87 / R8Kyle Pitts TECJ Nutter67.1126.8-59.7
#106 / R9Marquise Brown WRCJ Nutter0.067.1-67.1
#111 / R10Calvin Ridley WRCJ Nutter199.268.1+131.1
#130 / R11Jerry Jeudy WRCJ Nutter176.065.1+110.9
#135 / R12Cole Kmet TECJ Nutter52.580.8-28.3
#154 / R13Derek Carr QBCJ Nutter83.839.4+44.4
#159 / R14Jake Fromm QBCJ Nutter0.040.7-40.7
#178 / R15Phillip Lindsay RBCJ Nutter0.031.8-31.8
#183 / R16Curtis Samuel WRCJ Nutter0.039.9-39.9
#202 / R17Jay Ajayi RBCJ Nutter0.013.5-13.5
#207 / R18Derek Watt RBCJ Nutter0.022.3-22.3
#226 / R19Master Teague RBCJ Nutter0.035.8-35.8
#231 / R20Mike Gesicki TECJ Nutter7.030.0-23.0
#250 / R21Evan Hull RBCJ Nutter0.014.6-14.6
#255 / R22Miles Sanders RBCJ Nutter0.013.7-13.7
#274 / R23Dez Bryant WRCJ Nutter0.016.5-16.5
#279 / R24Jalen Tolbert WRCJ Nutter8.311.8-3.5
#298 / R25Marquez Valdes-Scantling WRCJ Nutter11.619.5-7.9
#303 / R26Demarcus Robinson WRCJ Nutter0.016.8-16.8
#322 / R27Tyler Bass KCJ Nutter129.014.9+114.1
#327 / R28Davis Allen TECJ Nutter0.012.0-12.0
#346 / R29Sean Tucker RBCJ Nutter0.014.4-14.4
#351 / R30Jalen Wydermyer TECJ Nutter0.011.4-11.4

Josh Bayer C

Won’t You Be My Nabers · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +9.7 points · total +290.1 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 5 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Cameron Dicker (#299, +139.9). Worst pick: Le'Veon Bell (#35, -143.6).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#11 / R1Justin Herbert QBJosh Bayer288.4240.3+48.1
#14 / R2Amon-Ra St. Brown WRJosh Bayer316.2239.8+76.3
#35 / R3Le'Veon Bell RBJosh Bayer0.0143.6-143.6
#38 / R4Drake London WRJosh Bayer280.8141.8+139.0
#59 / R5Kirk Cousins QBJosh Bayer186.2144.3+42.0
#62 / R6James Cook RBJosh Bayer266.7139.4+127.3
#83 / R7Alvin Kamara RBJosh Bayer265.3137.1+128.2
#86 / R8Terry McLaurin WRJosh Bayer241.5124.4+117.1
#107 / R9Christian Kirk WRJosh Bayer43.976.3-32.4
#110 / R10Danny Etling QBJosh Bayer0.063.8-63.8
#131 / R11Dalton Schultz TEJosh Bayer15.866.7-50.9
#134 / R12Raheem Mostert RBJosh Bayer26.078.9-52.9
#155 / R13Jerome Ford RBJosh Bayer61.135.0+26.1
#158 / R14Josh Rosen QBJosh Bayer0.037.7-37.7
#179 / R15Robert Turbin RBJosh Bayer0.037.0-37.0
#182 / R16Jalin Hyatt WRJosh Bayer0.036.6-36.6
#203 / R17Alfred Morris RBJosh Bayer0.016.2-16.2
#206 / R18Zay Jones WRJosh Bayer0.022.3-22.3
#227 / R19Kenneth Gainwell RBJosh Bayer0.032.2-32.2
#230 / R20Tyler Conklin TEJosh Bayer14.530.0-15.5
#251 / R21Elijah Mitchell RBJosh Bayer0.012.8-12.8
#254 / R22Mike Thomas WRJosh Bayer0.014.3-14.3
#275 / R23Houston Texans DEFJosh Bayer76.014.3+61.7
#278 / R24Jelani Woods TEJosh Bayer0.011.8-11.8
#299 / R25Cameron Dicker KJosh Bayer161.021.1+139.9
#302 / R26Ted Ginn WRJosh Bayer0.018.2-18.2
#323 / R27Jake Browning QBJosh Bayer0.013.3-13.3
#326 / R28Michael Carter RBJosh Bayer0.011.4-11.4
#347 / R29Virgil Green TEJosh Bayer0.013.4-13.4
#350 / R30Detroit Lions DEFJosh Bayer32.011.4+20.6

Bryan Stein C

steinb11 · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +7.7 points · total +230.8 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 6 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Aaron Rodgers (#85, +142.4). Worst pick: Brandon Aiyuk (#37, -80.3).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#12 / R1Joe Burrow QBBryan Stein381.8245.3+136.6
#13 / R2CeeDee Lamb WRBryan Stein263.4235.0+28.4
#36 / R3Travis Etienne RBBryan Stein130.2140.5-10.3
#37 / R4Brandon Aiyuk WRBryan Stein62.4142.7-80.3
#60 / R5Tee Higgins WRBryan Stein222.1148.2+73.9
#61 / R6Kenneth Walker RBBryan Stein167.3143.1+24.2
#84 / R7T.J. Hockenson TEBryan Stein86.5132.6-46.1
#85 / R8Aaron Rodgers QBBryan Stein267.6125.2+142.4
#108 / R9Diontae Johnson WRBryan Stein59.772.9-13.2
#109 / R10Sean Clifford QBBryan Stein0.067.3-67.3
#132 / R11Jordan Ta'amu QBBryan Stein0.065.1-65.1
#133 / R12Zach Charbonnet RBBryan Stein118.575.7+42.8
#156 / R13Darnell Mooney WRBryan Stein67.337.4+29.9
#157 / R14Cole McDonald QBBryan Stein0.037.6-37.6
#180 / R15Rashod Bateman WRBryan Stein16.139.6-23.5
#181 / R16Tyler Boyd WRBryan Stein0.041.1-41.1
#204 / R17Greg Dulcich TEBryan Stein7.817.1-9.3
#205 / R18Jacoby Brissett QBBryan Stein0.022.3-22.3
#228 / R19JuJu Smith-Schuster WRBryan Stein1.629.9-28.3
#229 / R20Philadelphia Eagles DEFBryan Stein122.027.1+94.9
#252 / R21Jake Elliott KBryan Stein14.011.4+2.6
#253 / R22Deuce Vaughn RBBryan Stein0.017.0-17.0
#276 / R23D'Onta Foreman RBBryan Stein0.014.8-14.8
#277 / R24Josh Gordon WRBryan Stein0.013.9-13.9
#300 / R25Jauan Jennings WRBryan Stein127.124.3+102.8
#301 / R26Charlie Jones WRBryan Stein0.021.5-21.5
#324 / R27Zach Ertz TEBryan Stein103.111.1+92.0
#325 / R28Cam Akers RBBryan Stein9.911.3-1.4
#348 / R29Jimmy Garoppolo QBBryan Stein0.013.4-13.4
#349 / R30Isaiah Spiller RBBryan Stein0.013.4-13.4

the Skeet C

johndennis · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +5.4 points · total +161.1 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 7 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Sam Darnold (#225, +181.7). Worst pick: Tim Tebow (#16, -229.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#9 / R1Justin Jefferson WRthe Skeet317.5259.5+57.9
#16 / R2Tim Tebow TEthe Skeet0.0229.2-229.2
#33 / R3Calvin Jackson WRthe Skeet0.0134.0-134.0
#40 / R4Kyren Williams RBthe Skeet272.1153.7+118.4
#57 / R5Zay Flowers WRthe Skeet209.5145.1+64.4
#64 / R6Josh Jacobs RBthe Skeet293.1131.7+161.4
#81 / R7Will Levis QBthe Skeet71.1128.8-57.8
#88 / R8Philip Rivers QBthe Skeet0.0127.0-127.0
#105 / R9Zamir White RBthe Skeet14.869.1-54.3
#112 / R10Tyjae Spears RBthe Skeet64.266.3-2.1
#129 / R11Daniel Jones QBthe Skeet40.672.9-32.3
#136 / R12Pat Freiermuth TEthe Skeet157.677.9+79.7
#153 / R13Jake Luton QBthe Skeet0.040.1-40.1
#160 / R14Kendre Miller RBthe Skeet8.044.1-36.1
#177 / R15Roschon Johnson RBthe Skeet0.027.7-27.7
#184 / R16Wan'Dale Robinson WRthe Skeet48.139.6+8.5
#201 / R17Noah Fant TEthe Skeet0.016.6-16.6
#208 / R18Aidan O'Connell QBthe Skeet2.122.9-20.8
#225 / R19Sam Darnold QBthe Skeet217.535.9+181.7
#232 / R20Alec Pierce WRthe Skeet65.420.7+44.7
#249 / R21Kendrick Bourne WRthe Skeet0.014.0-14.0
#256 / R22Dawson Knox TEthe Skeet7.514.9-7.4
#273 / R23Daniel Carlson Kthe Skeet137.014.7+122.3
#280 / R24Joe Flacco QBthe Skeet17.98.1+9.8
#297 / R25Donovan Peoples-Jones WRthe Skeet0.018.5-18.5
#304 / R26Allen Lazard WRthe Skeet33.219.7+13.5
#321 / R27Darnell Washington TEthe Skeet0.014.5-14.5
#328 / R28Samaje Perine RBthe Skeet0.010.7-10.7
#345 / R29Terrace Marshall WRthe Skeet0.08.2-8.2
#352 / R30Green Bay Packers DEFthe Skeet162.011.9+150.1

Carson Nutter D

cnutt · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +3.1 points · total +94.3 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 8 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Josh Allen (#1, +142.6). Worst pick: Robert Griffin (#49, -138.5).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#1 / R1Josh Allen QBCarson Nutter385.0242.5+142.6
#24 / R2Puka Nacua WRCarson Nutter206.6182.9+23.7
#25 / R3Trevor Lawrence QBCarson Nutter151.0168.7-17.7
#48 / R4Trey McBride TECarson Nutter249.8136.9+112.9
#49 / R5Robert Griffin QBCarson Nutter0.0138.5-138.5
#72 / R6Jayden Reed WRCarson Nutter197.0103.4+93.6
#73 / R7Najee Harris RBCarson Nutter204.6107.1+97.5
#96 / R8Chris Godwin WRCarson Nutter137.891.5+46.3
#97 / R9Jahan Dotson WRCarson Nutter0.093.7-93.7
#120 / R10David Njoku TECarson Nutter146.173.0+73.1
#121 / R11Brian Robinson RBCarson Nutter116.671.1+45.5
#144 / R12Mike Williams WRCarson Nutter4.553.7-49.2
#145 / R13Gus Edwards RBCarson Nutter33.953.3-19.4
#168 / R14Vincent Testaverde QBCarson Nutter0.042.9-42.9
#169 / R15David Blough QBCarson Nutter0.044.6-44.6
#192 / R16Jonathan Mingo WRCarson Nutter0.027.7-27.7
#193 / R17Rondale Moore WRCarson Nutter0.024.8-24.8
#216 / R18DJ Chark WRCarson Nutter0.032.5-32.5
#217 / R19AJ Dillon RBCarson Nutter0.031.7-31.7
#240 / R20Juwan Johnson TECarson Nutter4.222.8-18.6
#241 / R21Trey Palmer WRCarson Nutter0.025.6-25.6
#264 / R22Trey Lance QBCarson Nutter-0.313.3-13.6
#265 / R23Skyy Moore WRCarson Nutter0.015.9-15.9
#288 / R24Jamaal Williams RBCarson Nutter4.86.6-1.8
#289 / R25Calvin Austin WRCarson Nutter28.59.0+19.5
#312 / R26Hayden Hurst TECarson Nutter0.015.9-15.9
#313 / R27Noah Brown WRCarson Nutter37.512.9+24.6
#336 / R28Jake Bobo WRCarson Nutter0.04.5-4.5
#337 / R29Justyn Ross WRCarson Nutter0.06.5-6.5
#360 / R30Seattle Seahawks DEFCarson Nutter47.06.8+40.2

Nick Bayer D

Canton Condors · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +0.9 points · total +26.7 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 9 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jared Goff (#50, +201.3). Worst pick: Devlin Hodges (#74, -110.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#2 / R1C.J. Stroud QBNick Bayer232.4251.8-19.4
#23 / R2Garrett Wilson WRNick Bayer251.9190.4+61.5
#26 / R3Tyreek Hill WRNick Bayer218.2161.7+56.5
#47 / R4Michael Pittman WRNick Bayer76.8144.9-68.1
#50 / R5Jared Goff QBNick Bayer336.5135.2+201.3
#71 / R6Isiah Pacheco RBNick Bayer56.993.8-36.9
#74 / R7Devlin Hodges QBNick Bayer0.0110.2-110.2
#95 / R8Amari Cooper WRNick Bayer101.9102.4-0.5
#98 / R9Evan Engram TENick Bayer46.283.7-37.5
#119 / R10Devin Singletary RBNick Bayer14.081.8-67.8
#122 / R11Josh Downs WRNick Bayer127.771.6+56.1
#143 / R12Khalil Shakir WRNick Bayer141.359.1+82.2
#146 / R13Dontayvion Wicks WRNick Bayer12.940.0-27.1
#167 / R14Keaton Mitchell RBNick Bayer0.040.5-40.5
#170 / R15Sam Howell QBNick Bayer0.047.1-47.1
#191 / R16Chigoziem Okonkwo TENick Bayer0.032.8-32.8
#194 / R17Ty Chandler RBNick Bayer0.019.3-19.3
#215 / R18Khalil Herbert RBNick Bayer0.033.4-33.4
#218 / R19Bilal Powell RBNick Bayer0.028.3-28.3
#239 / R20Kansas City Chiefs DEFNick Bayer107.022.8+84.2
#242 / R21Evan McPherson KNick Bayer87.025.1+61.9
#263 / R22Kenny Golladay WRNick Bayer0.012.7-12.7
#266 / R23Travis Benjamin WRNick Bayer0.010.2-10.2
#287 / R24Kalil Pimpleton WRNick Bayer0.03.8-3.8
#290 / R25Colby Parkinson TENick Bayer0.010.5-10.5
#311 / R26Parker Washington WRNick Bayer0.017.3-17.3
#314 / R27Bo Melton WRNick Bayer0.013.8-13.8
#335 / R28Chris Rodriguez RBNick Bayer0.04.5-4.5
#338 / R29Blake Grupe KNick Bayer0.05.9-5.9
#359 / R30Miami Dolphins DEFNick Bayer77.06.5+70.5

codyis F

The Pittsburgh Wheelers · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: +0.1 points · total +3.9 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 10 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Saquon Barkley (#41, +202.5). Worst pick: Todd Gurley (#17, -224.0).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#8 / R1Kyler Murray QBcodyis283.1255.5+27.6
#17 / R2Todd Gurley RBcodyis0.0224.0-224.0
#32 / R3Marshawn Lynch RBcodyis0.0137.3-137.3
#41 / R4Saquon Barkley RBcodyis355.3152.8+202.5
#56 / R5Mark Andrews TEcodyis169.9155.9+14.0
#65 / R6George Pickens WRcodyis147.1125.3+21.8
#80 / R7Stefon Diggs WRcodyis121.9128.5-6.5
#89 / R8Joe Mixon RBcodyis240.5115.4+125.1
#104 / R9Justin Fields QBcodyis15.967.9-52.0
#113 / R10Jameson Williams WRcodyis145.274.0+71.2
#128 / R11Austin Ekeler RBcodyis64.775.1-10.4
#137 / R12Quentin Johnston WRcodyis28.670.8-42.2
#152 / R13Marvin Mims WRcodyis0.038.5-38.5
#161 / R14Luke Musgrave TEcodyis0.046.8-46.8
#176 / R15J.K. Dobbins RBcodyis114.131.0+83.1
#185 / R16Chuba Hubbard RBcodyis202.133.6+168.5
#200 / R17Dameon Pierce RBcodyis0.015.7-15.7
#209 / R18Taysom Hill TEcodyis9.722.9-13.2
#224 / R19Baltimore Ravens DEFcodyis69.039.3+29.7
#233 / R20Israel Abanikanda RBcodyis0.020.6-20.6
#248 / R21Hendon Hooker QBcodyis0.016.0-16.0
#257 / R22Michael Thomas WRcodyis0.014.3-14.3
#272 / R23Kenny Pickett QBcodyis0.015.2-15.2
#281 / R24John Metchie WRcodyis0.08.3-8.3
#296 / R25Greg Zuerlein Kcodyis5.017.4-12.4
#305 / R26Michael Gallup WRcodyis0.020.8-20.8
#320 / R27Desmond Ridder QBcodyis0.015.2-15.2
#329 / R28Zach Wilson QBcodyis0.07.6-7.6
#344 / R29Irv Smith TEcodyis0.08.3-8.3
#353 / R30Gerald Everett TEcodyis0.014.2-14.2

NOB42 F

The Amish · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: -0.2 points · total -5.1 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 11 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Geno Smith (#139, +176.0). Worst pick: DeShone Kizer (#43, -154.2).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#6 / R1Bijan Robinson RBNOB42341.7252.7+89.0
#19 / R2Jordan Love QBNOB42196.7209.5-12.7
#30 / R3Sam LaPorta TENOB4274.8126.0-51.2
#43 / R4DeShone Kizer QBNOB420.0154.2-154.2
#54 / R5Travis Kelce TENOB42195.4146.0+49.4
#67 / R6Rhamondre Stevenson RBNOB42134.8111.8+23.0
#78 / R7Mike Evans WRNOB42240.4129.4+111.0
#91 / R8Chris Oladokun QBNOB420.0108.7-108.7
#102 / R9Nick Chubb RBNOB4236.567.6-31.1
#115 / R10Russell Wilson QBNOB420.074.7-74.7
#126 / R11Brogan Roback QBNOB420.076.1-76.1
#139 / R12Geno Smith QBNOB42238.562.4+176.0
#150 / R13Michael Wilson WRNOB4212.834.9-22.1
#163 / R14Tyler Allgeier RBNOB420.046.9-46.9
#174 / R15DeMario Douglas WRNOB4247.337.4+9.9
#187 / R16Adam Thielen WRNOB4295.034.0+61.0
#198 / R17Theo Riddick RBNOB420.016.2-16.2
#211 / R18Brandon Aubrey KNOB42139.023.9+115.1
#222 / R19Dallas Cowboys DEFNOB4231.037.9-6.9
#235 / R20Drew Lock QBNOB420.023.5-23.5
#246 / R21Jake Funk RBNOB420.018.4-18.4
#259 / R22Tre Tucker WRNOB4211.114.8-3.7
#270 / R23Cleveland Browns DEFNOB4212.015.1-3.1
#283 / R24Jeremy Ruckert TENOB420.07.4-7.4
#294 / R25Jonnu Smith TENOB4275.618.5+57.1
#307 / R26Jarrett Stidham QBNOB420.014.5-14.5
#318 / R27Mac Jones QBNOB420.016.4-16.4
#331 / R28Noah Gray TENOB4215.54.0+11.5
#342 / R29Lance Kendricks TENOB420.07.1-7.1
#355 / R30Feleipe Franks TENOB420.013.2-13.2

Colby Nutter F

TheBeans69 · 30 picks · 30 graded

Average vs slot: -6.4 points · total -191.6 ÷ 30 graded picks · rank 12 of 12 graded teams.

Best pick: Jahmyr Gibbs (#18, +143.2). Worst pick: Drew Brees (#90, -111.1).

Overall / roundPlayerOriginal ownerYear-one pointsSlot baselinevs slot / status
#7 / R1Anthony Richardson QBColby Nutter147.3250.1-102.8
#18 / R2Jahmyr Gibbs RBColby Nutter362.9219.7+143.2
#31 / R3Jaylen Waddle WRColby Nutter80.0127.5-47.5
#42 / R4De'Von Achane RBColby Nutter299.9159.8+140.1
#55 / R5Rashee Rice WRColby Nutter64.9145.8-80.9
#66 / R6Tank Dell WRColby Nutter140.0119.0+21.0
#79 / R7Deshaun Watson QBColby Nutter79.7128.1-48.4
#90 / R8Drew Brees QBColby Nutter0.0111.1-111.1
#103 / R9Javonte Williams RBColby Nutter47.065.9-18.9
#114 / R10Christian Watson WRColby Nutter32.768.2-35.5
#127 / R11Dallas Goedert TEColby Nutter94.182.5+11.6
#138 / R12Romeo Doubs WRColby Nutter55.764.3-8.6
#151 / R13Gabe Davis WRColby Nutter26.339.7-13.4
#162 / R14Joshua Palmer WRColby Nutter0.046.6-46.6
#175 / R15Tucker Kraft TEColby Nutter104.436.2+68.2
#186 / R16Cedric Tillman WRColby Nutter22.333.7-11.4
#199 / R17Brandin Cooks WRColby Nutter3.616.3-12.7
#210 / R18Lamar Miller RBColby Nutter0.022.6-22.6
#223 / R19Alexander Mattison RBColby Nutter31.939.8-7.9
#234 / R20A.T. Perry WRColby Nutter0.020.9-20.9
#247 / R21Geronimo Allison WRColby Nutter0.018.1-18.1
#258 / R22Tutu Atwell WRColby Nutter12.515.8-3.3
#271 / R23Jake Moody KColby Nutter71.013.6+57.4
#282 / R24Darius Slayton WRColby Nutter11.77.0+4.7
#295 / R25Chase Claypool WRColby Nutter0.017.9-17.9
#306 / R26Eric Gray RBColby Nutter0.016.4-16.4
#319 / R27Justin Shorter WRColby Nutter0.016.2-16.2
#330 / R28Jared Cook TEColby Nutter0.07.7-7.7
#343 / R29Washington Commanders DEFColby Nutter51.07.1+43.9
#354 / R30Charles Clay TEColby Nutter0.013.1-13.1